Breaking News
January 22, 2018 - Study identifies new loci associated with asthma enriched in epigenetic marks
January 22, 2018 - Specially prepared supplement helps women to run faster, study shows
January 22, 2018 - 3-D Stent Retriever with Aspiration Proves Mettle in AIS
January 22, 2018 - Public health research seeks to understand how natural disasters impact spread of Zika
January 22, 2018 - Research reveals role of nanophenomenon in stimulating bone-repair process
January 22, 2018 - Epilepsy associated with volume and thickness differences in brain matter
January 22, 2018 - Trevena Announces FDA Acceptance for Review of New Drug Application for Olinvo (oliceridine) Injection
January 22, 2018 - A Noteworthy Margin of Error
January 22, 2018 - Firm advances human trials of revolutionary vaccine
January 22, 2018 - Many Indians put away treating orthopedic problems
January 22, 2018 - Cherwell releases new pocket guide to prepared culture media
January 22, 2018 - Huron earns ISO 13485 certification for quality management system
January 22, 2018 - Avion Pharmaceuticals Announces FDA Approval of Balcoltra (levonorgestrel and ethinyl estradiol tablets and ferrous bisglycinate tablets) Oral Contraceptive
January 22, 2018 - Multi-Gene Test For Early CVD; Neighborhood HF Risk; Novel Testosterone Drugs
January 22, 2018 - Skipping breakfast disrupts ‘clock genes’ that regulate body weight
January 22, 2018 - Creativity May Rely on ‘Teamwork’ in the Brain
January 22, 2018 - NeuroBreak: Alzheimer’s Germ Contest; High Salt Diet May Be Bad for Brain
January 22, 2018 - Diabetics may often fare poorly in hospice care
January 22, 2018 - Performance enhancing benefits of caffeine more apparent for infrequent tea, coffee drinkers
January 22, 2018 - HHS Unveils Framework for Interoperability
January 22, 2018 - More dentists to discuss risks of HPV-related cancers with their patients
January 21, 2018 - Research shows how Zika virus damages placenta to cause malformations in babies
January 21, 2018 - Achaogen Announces FDA Acceptance of New Drug Application with Priority Review for Plazomicin for Treatment of Complicated Urinary Tract Infections and Bloodstream Infections
January 21, 2018 - Drug Allergies: Time to Re-Test?
January 21, 2018 - Mitochondrial protein in cardiac muscle cells linked to heart failure, study finds
January 21, 2018 - Women more likely than men to die from a heart attack
January 21, 2018 - Next generation genomic sequencing can help detect pathogens after joint replacement
January 21, 2018 - Gov’t Shutdown Looms as Senate Debates Spending Bill
January 21, 2018 - Emergency Readiness for Older Adults and People with Disabilities
January 21, 2018 - Heart health at risk for Latinas over worries about deportation
January 21, 2018 - Scientists methodically identify genes related to blood feeding and non-biting mosquitoes
January 21, 2018 - Researchers discover potential target genes to halt thyroid cancer progression
January 21, 2018 - Youth with shared residency after parents’ divorce have less mental issues
January 21, 2018 - Sleep Better, Lose Weight? – Drugs.com MedNews
January 21, 2018 - More $$ Needed for Health Emergencies, Senators Told
January 21, 2018 - Gene test to predict breast cancer recurrence less cost effective in real world practice
January 21, 2018 - Study finds rise in number of adolescents receiving psychiatric or neurodevelopmental diagnosis
January 21, 2018 - Reminders can improve immunization rates
January 21, 2018 - A More Personalized Approach to PSA Screening in 2017
January 21, 2018 - T-cells engineered to outsmart tumors induce clinical responses in relapsed Hodgkin lymphoma
January 21, 2018 - Tetraphase Pharmaceuticals Announces Submission of New Drug Application to FDA for Eravacycline for the Treatment of Complicated Intra-Abdominal Infections (cIAI)
January 21, 2018 - Have Robotics Had a Detrimental Effect on Surgical Residency?
January 21, 2018 - Being bilingual may help autistic children
January 21, 2018 - Metrics Are Not Widespread in Rheumatoid Care
January 21, 2018 - Neuroanatomic abnormalities ID’d in those at risk for autism
January 21, 2018 - Children born with Down’s syndrome have superior genome that compensates for disability
January 21, 2018 - Study finds higher risks for asymptomatic paroxysmal AF patients
January 21, 2018 - The Second Stage of Diet Resolutions
January 21, 2018 - CT Scans Reduce Lung Cancer Deaths … But Among Whom?
January 21, 2018 - ADHD drug use soars among young women
January 21, 2018 - Researchers propose new regulation mechanism linked to action of SirT6 on chromatin
January 21, 2018 - Statins appear to reduce risk of repeated surgery in patients who undergo vitrectomy
January 21, 2018 - Morning Break: Hep A Outbreak Spreads; Tide Pod Challenge; Keeping Lobsters Out of Hot Water
January 21, 2018 - EULAR and ACR present SLE classification criteria at the 2017 ACR/ARHP Annual Meeting
January 21, 2018 - Progenics Pharmaceuticals Announces FDA Acceptance of New Drug Application for Azedra (iobenguane I 131) in Pheochromocytoma and Paraganglioma
January 21, 2018 - House Passes Funding Bill with 6-Year CHIP Renewal
January 21, 2018 - DASH ranked Best Diet Overall for eighth year in a row by U.S. News and World Report
January 21, 2018 - Dementia study sheds light on how damage spreads through brain
January 20, 2018 - Morning Break: Missing Maria Deaths; N.J. Doc Charged in Wife’s Murder; Viva Vaseline!
January 20, 2018 - No interventions proven to prevent late-life dementia
January 20, 2018 - Judge orders new Olympus trial over superbug death
January 20, 2018 - Don’t Rely on Just One Blood Pressure Test for Kids: Study
January 20, 2018 - Going Off the Deep End About Water
January 20, 2018 - Parental attention can reduce risk of drug abuse in adolescence
January 20, 2018 - Mast Uri System offers efficient and cost-friendly diagnostic solution
January 20, 2018 - International SOS, Chatham House sign partnership agreement to further advance Global Health Security Agenda
January 20, 2018 - Study offers way to predict onset of lung disease in children with cystic fibrosis
January 20, 2018 - C-Suite Must Lead in Ending Sexual Harassment
January 20, 2018 - Researchers find a way to ‘starve’ cancer
January 20, 2018 - Applied math can help predict genesis and evolution of different cancers
January 20, 2018 - UCLA researchers describe herpes virus structure associated with Kaposi’s sarcoma
January 20, 2018 - New study enrolls first patient to evaluate potential of WaveCrest LAAO System
January 20, 2018 - New review explores effects of exposing developing brains to general anesthesia
January 20, 2018 - GW Pharmaceuticals Announces Acceptance of NDA Filing for Epidiolex (cannabidiol) in the treatment of Lennox-Gastaut syndrome and Dravet syndrome
January 20, 2018 - Weight-Loss Surgery Approaches Offer Similar Results
January 20, 2018 - Free online access to millions of documents on chemical toxicity
January 20, 2018 - CE marked MAST Toxoreagent kit for detection of Toxoplasma antibodies
January 20, 2018 - DNA study sheds light on longstanding puzzle of cell division
January 20, 2018 - Montefiore provides specialized medical care to parents of adopted children
January 20, 2018 - Enzyme discovery provides new horizon of therapeutic opportunities across disease spectrum
Gene Screens Can Alter Perception, Behavior

Gene Screens Can Alter Perception, Behavior

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Action Points

  • Note that two studies of false genetic information demonstrated that patients will endorse risks and behaviors that they are told they are genetically susceptible to.
  • This highlights the need for careful counseling prior to genetic testing, as results can influence behavior.

Personal genetic information can create a powerful filter that could produce harmful changes in perception and behavior, according to two studies from a research team at Yale University.

People who were told their genes predisposed them to depression reported higher levels of depressive symptoms than people without this knowledge, reported Matthew Lebowitz, PhD, now at Columbia University, and Yale psychology professor Woo-kyoung Ahn, PhD, in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. And people who were told they genetically were not predisposed to obesity were much more likely to choose unhealthy foods than people without this information, they wrote in the journal Appetite.

“While potential benefits of making genetic information available seem to be well understood, there may be a downside that needs to be grappled with,” Lebowitz told MedPage Today. “Now is a good time for the field to be thinking about these issues, before personalized genetic testing becomes widespread in more areas of healthcare.”

In both studies, Lebowitz and Ahn used a saliva test disguised as genetic screening. The researchers debriefed all participants after they completed the studies, explaining no actual genetic testing had been conducted.

In the study about depression, they set out to determine whether past experiences of psychiatric symptoms could be distorted by misunderstandings about genetics.

“Mental health disorders are diagnosed on the basis of subjective self-report; we diagnose people based on them telling us what they remember about the symptoms they experienced,” Lebowitz explained. “Anything that could distort or alter people’s memories of their symptoms potentially could interfere with the accuracy of diagnoses.”

Lebowitz and Ahn recruited participants for two experiments in this study through Amazon’s online Mechanical Turk (MTurk) platform, a service that lets individuals complete tasks in exchange for pay. In the first experiment (n=429), participants had an average age of 32.5, and 47.3% had a bachelor’s or postgraduate degree. In the second experiment (n=741), the average was 34.8 and 54.6% of participants held a bachelor’s or postgraduate degree. In both groups, slightly more than half of the participants — about 53% — were female.

The researchers mailed saliva testing kits to participants, leading them to believe the test was a way to gauge genetic susceptibility to depression. They assigned participants randomly to one of several conditions, including:

• Gene-absent, in which participants were told they did not carry a gene predisposing them to depression;

• Gene-present, in which participants were told they did carry the gene; and

• Gene-present/intervention, in which participants were told they carried the gene, but also reviewed an intervention video that explained that genes alone do not deterministically cause major depression and discussed actions people can take to decrease their risk of depression if they are predisposed genetically. In previous work by Lebowitz and Ahn, this video successfully restored feelings of agency over depression, even among people who attributed depression to biological causes.

The researchers asked participants whether they ever had experienced major depression — at least one episode of a low mood that lasted most of the day, almost every day for at least two weeks — and had them complete the Beck Depression Inventory II (BDI-II) to measure depressive symptoms over the past 2 weeks. Possible BDI-II scores ranged from 0 to 60, with higher scores indicating more symptomology.

They found that a larger proportion of patients in both the gene-present and gene-present/intervention groups had greater reporting of having experienced a major depressive episode. Both groups also had significantly higher BDI-II scores than those in the gene-absent group. This suggests that the intervention video didn’t affects respondents’ recall of depression symptoms, the researchers noted.

In the study published in Appetite, the researchers used similar methodology to see what food choices people would make if they thought they were not genetically predisposed to obesity. Participants were asked to pretend they were preordering lunch for a daylong meeting and to select a meal from a list that contained healthy (chicken Caesar salad wrap, salad with grilled chicken, and roasted turkey and avocado sandwich) and unhealthy choices (cheeseburger, meatloaf with mashed potatoes, and baked ziti with three cheeses). The researchers also asked six questions about the importance of diet and exercise on a scale of 1 (not important) to 7 (very important).

This test group was mostly women (60.2%) between 18 and 39 years old (76%). Most considered themselves to be normal weight (45.6%), though 38.9% said they were overweight and 13.7% said they were obese.

After controlling for current weight status, Lebowitz and Ahn saw that 15.7% of the people in the gene-present condition selected an unhealthy option, compared to 28.8% in the gene-absent condition. The only independent variable that emerged as significant was the one representing gene-absent feedback, indicating that this information significantly increased participants’ likelihood of selecting unhealthy choices, not their weight.

The importance of diet and exercise also was significantly lower among people in the gene-absent condition than those in the gene-present condition, they reported.

“Test results we tend to think of as good news can have potentially harmful side effects,” Lebowitz said. “When we told people they didn’t have a genetic predisposition to obesity, they underrated the importance of healthy diet and exercise.”

The findings of both studies have clinical importance, Lebowitz noted. Previous research has shown that the more people attribute their depressive symptoms to genetics and other biological factors, the more pessimistic they are about the future. And in depression and other mental health disorders, he added, subjective experiences may lay the groundwork for future health.

“If subjective experiences are being altered, it could create a negative feedback loop,” Lebowitz explained. “Thinking of yourself as a depressed person can potentially lead to you being more depressed.”

Both studies were limited in that they examined only short-term effects of personalized genetic feedback, since ethically, deception about the saliva test could not be extended. The authors noted that the effects they saw might be more pronounced in disorders that are viewed as more genetically based, and less pronounced in cases in which genes are seen as less determinative.

The studies were funded by the National Institutes of Health. The authors reported no conflicts of interest.

  • Reviewed by
    F. Perry Wilson, MD, MSCE Assistant Professor, Section of Nephrology, Yale School of Medicine and Dorothy Caputo, MA, BSN, RN, Nurse Planner

2017-10-31T16:15:00-0400

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles