Breaking News
January 20, 2018 - MSU scientists seek to identify brain mechanisms related to psychosis
January 20, 2018 - Syndax Pharmaceuticals Announces Clinical Collaboration to Evaluate Entinostat in Combination with anti-PD-L1 Cancer Immunotherapy in Breast Cancer
January 20, 2018 - Endoscopes Over Microscopes in Retinal Surgery: Ophthalmology Times
January 20, 2018 - Technology not taking over children’s lives despite screen-time increase
January 20, 2018 - Study finds extensive contamination around lead battery recycling plants in 7 African countries
January 20, 2018 - Flu may pass to others through exhaled breath, study shows
January 20, 2018 - Neuronal loss very limited in Alzheimer’s disease, new study shows
January 20, 2018 - Novel robot can aid treatment of rare birth defect
January 19, 2018 - TherapeuticsMD Announces Submission of New Drug Application for TX-001HR
January 19, 2018 - Fighting Infant Mortality | Medpage Today
January 19, 2018 - Researchers offer new evidence on four-year-old children’s knowledge about ecology
January 19, 2018 - Analysis finds overlooked crucial factor in determining prognosis for DIPGs
January 19, 2018 - Review explores consequences of genetic testing and cancer risk-reducing surgery
January 19, 2018 - Morning Break: HHS Div. of Religious Freedom; Trump’s Heart Health; Minister of Loneliness
January 19, 2018 - Parkinson’s disease ‘jerking’ side effect detected by algorithm
January 19, 2018 - New analysis finds dramatic increases in maternal mortality rates
January 19, 2018 - Weight-Loss Surgery’s Benefits Wane Over Time for Diabetics
January 19, 2018 - Cath Lab Recap: Sapien 3 Delivery System Recall; Transatlantic PCI Smackdown
January 19, 2018 - Parkinson’s treatment could be more effective, student finds
January 19, 2018 - New vaccine approach offers effective protection against tuberculosis
January 19, 2018 - Home care agencies often wrongly deny Medicare help to the chronically ill
January 19, 2018 - One hundred percent fruit juice does not alter blood sugar levels
January 19, 2018 - Prebiotics could enhance learning and memory skills in infants
January 19, 2018 - CMS May Cover MRI With Cardiac Devices Across the Board
January 19, 2018 - As income rises, women get slimmer—but not men
January 19, 2018 - Researchers develop adhesive materials to prevent bracket stains on teeth
January 19, 2018 - Flu can be spread without coughs and sneezes
January 19, 2018 - AMSBIO’s new recombinant protein shows great promise for organoid culture
January 19, 2018 - AbbVie’s Upadacitinib Granted Breakthrough Therapy Designation from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for Atopic Dermatitis
January 19, 2018 - ASH: Pomalidomide Dose Escalation Improves Response
January 19, 2018 - Is your child’s school an obesity risk?
January 19, 2018 - Scientists describe groundbreaking training effect on the innate immune system
January 19, 2018 - MAST announces new AmpC, ESBL & Carbapenemase Detection Set
January 19, 2018 - Signaling molecules likely involved in concussions, rodent studies show
January 19, 2018 - Mast introduces Carba plus for CPE and OXA-48 confirmation
January 19, 2018 - Paleolithic diet helps overweight women maintain weight loss
January 19, 2018 - Agios Submits New Drug Application to the FDA for Ivosidenib for the Treatment of Patients with Relapsed/Refractory AML and an IDH1 Mutation
January 19, 2018 - This Flu Season, Don’t Forget About Tamiflu
January 19, 2018 - Amsterdam wins battle to host EU medicines agency after Brexit
January 19, 2018 - Study suggests movement as accurate method to diagnose neurodevelopmental disorders
January 19, 2018 - Maximize resolution in deep imaging for neuroscience research with Olympus TruResolution objectives
January 19, 2018 - Bilingualism may benefit children with ASD
January 19, 2018 - FDA Alert: Levofloxacin in 5 Percent Dextrose 250mg/50mL by AuroMedics: Recall
January 19, 2018 - USPSTF Not Backing Ankle-Brachial Index, CRP, or Coronary Calcium
January 19, 2018 - Higher omega-3 fatty acid intake tied to lower glaucoma risk
January 19, 2018 - Findings reveal conventional cancer therapy as double-edged sword
January 19, 2018 - Health Highlights: Jan. 16, 2018
January 19, 2018 - Morning Break: Anti-Emetic Warning; Uninsured Rate Jumps; Flu Worsens Saline Shortage
January 19, 2018 - Increased use of ambulatory surgery centers for cataract surgery
January 19, 2018 - Not-for-profit hospitals coming up with their own generic medicines to combat shortages
January 19, 2018 - $500 cancer detection blood tests may soon become reality
January 19, 2018 - Chronic traumatic encephalopathy may start early even without signs of concussions
January 19, 2018 - Warm-up program for children cuts soccer injuries by 50%
January 19, 2018 - ‘You’re Old and You Need Tests’: What We Heard This Week
January 19, 2018 - Egg-preserving hysterectomy raises heart risks later: study
January 19, 2018 - GA-map Dysbiosis Test identifies IBS patients who respond to FODMAP diet, study shows
January 19, 2018 - Study explores mortality and health-related habits in former elite athletes and their brothers
January 19, 2018 - New biodegradable sensors could assist doctors
January 19, 2018 - Modular gene enhancers may be suitable target in treatment of blood cancer
January 18, 2018 - New precision medicine trial for metastatic pancreatic cancer
January 18, 2018 - Shire Receives FDA Breakthrough Therapy Designation for Maribavir, an Investigational Treatment for Cytomegalovirus (CMV) Infection in Transplant Patients
January 18, 2018 - Pre-Existing Patient-Valve Mismatch Trips Up ViV Implant
January 18, 2018 - Adolescents: health risks and solutions
January 18, 2018 - US woman delivers baby from embryo frozen for 24 years
January 18, 2018 - Study identifies new target for treatment of depression
January 18, 2018 - LJI study reveals key player that promotes skin inflammation in atopic dermatitis
January 18, 2018 - Study devises efficient and economical strategy to screen breast and ovarian cancer gene mutations
January 18, 2018 - Agile Therapeutics, Inc. Receives a Complete Response Letter from the FDA for Twirla (AG200-15) for the Prevention of Pregnancy
January 18, 2018 - Gene Therapy for Inherited Retinal Dystrophy Gets FDA Clearance
January 18, 2018 - Researchers identify a new chemical pathway that helps the brain detect sweet, savory and bitter flavors
January 18, 2018 - IBV develops platform that helps companies to diagnose wellbeing of their workforce
January 18, 2018 - Study to test new precision medicine approach for metastatic pancreatic cancer
January 18, 2018 - World’s first vaccine relieves grass pollen allergy symptoms by at least 25%, study shows
January 18, 2018 - FDA Approves New Indication for Gilotrif (afatinib) in EGFR Mutation-Positive NSCLC
January 18, 2018 - Oncologists Dish on Top Issues for 2018
January 18, 2018 - Researchers identify new potential drug target for Huntington’s disease
January 18, 2018 - Metrohm USA welcomes employees to new headquarters in Florida
January 18, 2018 - Human waste remains main source of fecal pollution in the river Danube
January 18, 2018 - Expert discusses how to stay healthy during flu season
January 18, 2018 - New biomaterials-based system improves T-cell production
Are Eye Docs Overdiagnosing Optic Neuritis?

Are Eye Docs Overdiagnosing Optic Neuritis?

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Action Points

  • The incidence of acute optic neuritis overdiagnosis may higher than previously thought because of clinicians who don’t conduct a thorough patient history or physical exam, and don’t generate a complete differential diagnosis.
  • Sixty percent of patients had an alternative diagnosis, most commonly primary headache disorder with eye pain.

The incidence of acute optic neuritis overdiagnosis may higher than previously thought because of clinicians who don’t conduct a thorough patient history or physical exam, and don’t generate a complete differential diagnosis, researchers said.

A retrospective study of patients referred to a university-based neuro-ophthalmology clinic for acute optic neuritis suggested that almost 60% of patients had an alternative diagnosis, according to Gregory P. Van Stavern, MD, of Washington University School of Medicine in St Louis, and colleagues.

While optic neuritis was confirmed in 49 patients (40.2%), 73 patients (59.8%) had something else, most commonly primary headache disorder with eye pain, they wrote online in JAMA Ophthalmology.

“These data, if representative of other neuro-ophthalmology practices, suggest that between 51% and 69% of patients referred for optic neuritis may have an alternative diagnosis, regardless of whether the patient was referred by an optometrist, ophthalmologist, or neurologist,” the authors stated. “Overdiagnosis in patients with alternative conditions may lead to unnecessary MRIs, lumbar punctures, treatments, loss of time, and expense.”

For the study, neuro-ophthalmologists determined definite diagnosis in 122 patients referred for optic neuritis from January 2014 to October 2016. Eighty-eight patients (72.1%) were female, and the mean age was 42.6. Data were analyzed from September 2016 to July 2017.

The most common clinician error was over-reliance on a single item of history and failure to consider alternative diagnoses. In 24 of 73 patients (33%) with an alternative diagnosis, clinicians didn’t elicit or interpret critical elements of patient history, the researchers said.

Even when alternative diagnoses was considered, too many clinicians failed to get things right. Not only were errors in alternative diagnoses made in 23 patients (32%), but physical exam findings were misinterpreted in 15 patients (21%) and diagnostic test results were misinterpreted in 11 patients (15%).

In many cases, diagnostic error reflected errors in reasoning or cognitive biases, such as premature closure, rather than lack of knowledge, Van Stavern’s group noted.

“Understanding pitfalls leading to over-diagnosis of optic neuritis may improve clinicians’ diagnostic process,” they said. “Eye pain should be considered in context with other symptoms, and headache, nonarteritic ischemic optic neuropathy (NAION), functional visual loss, and other alternative diagnoses should be considered in the differential diagnosis.”

The presence of a new relative afferent pupillary defect (APD) “was one of the more consistent examination findings that correlated with a true diagnosis of optic neuritis,” the researchers emphasized. “The lack of an APD strongly argues against a diagnosis of acute optic neuritis unless there is bilateral optic nerve involvement.”

“Eye care physicians should be able to do better,” Neil R. Miller, MD, of Johns Hopkins Medicine in Baltimore, told MedPage Today.

General ophthalmologists and optometrists tend to see patients with cataracts and glaucoma or an abnormality in the ocular fundus, explained Miller, who was not affiliated with the study. “In most cases, a simple examination is all that is needed to identify correctly most eye problems.”

When a patient presents with a disorder than isn’t related to the optic nerve, however, such as dry eye or unexplained non-organic visual loss, many general ophthalmologists get “stymied,” he said. A complete history and thorough physical exam will lead to the correct diagnosis in most cases, but many clinicians feel they are too busy to take the time, Miller added.

The study also revealed that the most common alternative diagnosis — primary headache disorder with associated eye pain and/or visual symptoms — was seen in 16 patients (22%). Functional visual loss was seen in 14 patients (19%). Other optic neuropathies, particularly NAION, was seen in nine patients (12%). Retinopathies such as neuroretinitis, central retinal artery occlusion, or branch retinal artery occlusion, were seen in 11 patients (15%).

Less frequent alternative diagnoses included ocular surface disease, congenital disc abnormalities and optic nerve sheath meningioma, seen in three patients each (4%).

Twelve patients (16%) who were referred for optic neuritis had normal findings on MR imaging, despite the fact that it is 94% sensitive to detection of optic neuritis.

“Discounting normal examination findings was a common source of diagnostic error in this study,” the researchers pointed out. “Normal [MRI] examination findings are reassuring and virtually exclude the diagnosis of acute optic neuritis.”

The study also showed that 12 patients (16%) had undergone lumbar puncture and 8 (11%) had received unnecessary treatment with intravenous steroids.

When a patient presents with eye pain, with or without eye movement, this symptom should raise concern for optic neuritis, they advised. However, when there is no associated visual loss, a primary headache disorder should also be considered.

The time course of eye pain and visual loss can also provide important diagnostic clues. “Several patients in our study described discrete, stereotyped episodes of visual loss most consistent with migraine aura, a pattern that would be extraordinarily unusual for optic neuritis,” Van Stavern’s group pointed out.

In patients with a known diagnosis of multiple sclerosis who were more likely to have optic neuritis, 4% still had an alternative diagnosis.

“It used to be that the biggest concern about misdiagnosis of optic neuritis was missing a diagnosis of a compression lesion, such as pituitary adenoma or intracranial aneurysm,” noted Miller. “This no longer appears to be the case, probably because doctors who are missing the diagnosis of optic neuritis are ordering neuroimaging and making the correct diagnosis.”

Study limitations included dependence on referral records for determining the source of diagnostic error.

The study was supported by Washington University, the Institute for Clinical and Translational Sciences, Biostat Core, Research to Prevent Blindness, and the National Institutes of Health.

Van Stavern and co-authors disclosed no relevant relationships with industry.

  • Reviewed by
    Robert Jasmer, MD Associate Clinical Professor of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco and Dorothy Caputo, MA, BSN, RN, Nurse Planner


last updated

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles