Breaking News
October 22, 2018 - Not exercising is worse than smoking, diabetes or heart disease finds study
October 22, 2018 - Shorter course of trastuzumab could be an option for women with HER2+ early breast cancer
October 22, 2018 - Map of Mouse Hippocampus Could Be Weapon Against Alzheimer’s
October 22, 2018 - Psychotropic polypharmacy is common in Alzheimer’s disease
October 22, 2018 - Texas A&M and UTA establish Texas Genomics Core Alliance
October 22, 2018 - Analyzing mouse’s potential as animal model of decision-making
October 22, 2018 - Radiotherapy can prolong survival in prostate cancer
October 22, 2018 - A genetic mutation involved in relapse
October 21, 2018 - Report reveals growing impact of cannabis on young people
October 21, 2018 - NSF awards $5 million grant to help scientists magnify societal impact of research
October 21, 2018 - Fertility Rates Down for Each Urbanization Level 2007 to 2017
October 21, 2018 - Genetically engineered 3-D human muscle transplant in a murine model
October 21, 2018 - Moms’ tight work schedules may affect their children’s sleep
October 21, 2018 - AHA: No Direct Link Between Preeclampsia and Cognitive Impairment, Study Finds
October 21, 2018 - Weight loss success linked with active self-control regions of the brain
October 21, 2018 - Scripps researchers successfully test potential new smoking-cessation treatment in rodents
October 21, 2018 - More accurate and less stressful way to measure a baby’s heartbeat
October 21, 2018 - Researchers show better cardiorespiratory fitness leads to longer life
October 21, 2018 - Healthy candies for diabetic patients
October 21, 2018 - Environment impact of microplastics remains unclear
October 21, 2018 - Antibiotics for appendicitis? Surgery often not needed
October 21, 2018 - AHA and AMA recognize more than 800 medical practices, health systems for blood pressure control
October 21, 2018 - Scientists obtain clearest ever image of Ebola virus protein
October 21, 2018 - Study reveals connection between two proteins known to be hyperactive in cancer
October 21, 2018 - Gabapentin Beats Pregabalin for Chronic Sciatica
October 21, 2018 - Cosmetic surgeons offering incomplete information for breast augmentation customers
October 21, 2018 - Chronic sleep disruption in early adult life accelerates AD-related tau pathology
October 21, 2018 - Take 10 for Mindfulness – Drugs.com MedNews
October 21, 2018 - Length of breathing disruption in OSA may be better predictor of mortality risk
October 21, 2018 - ApoE4 gene linked with chronic inflammation increases risk for Alzheimer’s disease
October 21, 2018 - Mother-daughter conflict associated with suicide risk in abused adolescent girls
October 21, 2018 - Scientists molding bacteria into unnatural shapes
October 21, 2018 - High diet quality associated with lower risk of death in colorectal cancer patients
October 21, 2018 - Discharged mental health patients ‘at greater risk of dying’
October 21, 2018 - Research provides insight into neurobiology of aggression and bullying
October 21, 2018 - As billions in tax dollars flow to private Medicaid plans, Who’s minding the store?
October 21, 2018 - Neuroscientists identify brain region that appears to be related to food preference decisions
October 21, 2018 - Deaths related to air pollution in the U.S. decreased by 47% between 1990 and 2010
October 21, 2018 - Study shows correlation between spatial memory and the sense of smell
October 21, 2018 - Increased cardiorespiratory fitness associated with reduced long-term mortality
October 21, 2018 - IU researchers receive $1.55 million from NIH to improve chronic-disease management
October 21, 2018 - Income and wealth affect the mental health of Australians, study shows
October 21, 2018 - Patients with hypertension and psoriasis more often require cardiovascular interventions
October 20, 2018 - Leading hip-hop videos depict use of tobacco and marijuana products, study finds
October 20, 2018 - Dose Range of IV Ketamine for Adjunct Tx of Depression Tested
October 20, 2018 - Infants can distinguish between leaders and bullies, study finds
October 20, 2018 - Mad Cow disease found on Aberdeenshire farm
October 20, 2018 - Study identifies factors associated with prescription opioid misuse among students
October 20, 2018 - Scientists uncover key regulator of mTORC1 in cancer growth
October 20, 2018 - Pounds Regained After Weight-Loss Op Can Tell Your Doc a Lot
October 20, 2018 - Sending parents letters to fight childhood obesity doesn’t work
October 20, 2018 - Supervised aerobic exercise can support major depression treatment
October 20, 2018 - Mindfulness-based program effective for reducing stress in infertile women
October 20, 2018 - Molecule capable of halting and reverting neurodegeneration caused by Parkinson’s disease identified
October 20, 2018 - Midazolam-mediated alterations of PER2 expression may have functional consequences during myocardial ischemia
October 20, 2018 - Sweat bees are ideal for studying the genes underlying social behavior
October 20, 2018 - Weight loss success associated with brain areas involved in self-control
October 20, 2018 - KHN’s ‘What the Health?’ Republicans’ preexisting political problem
October 20, 2018 - Research provides a more complete picture of suffering caused by terrorist attacks
October 20, 2018 - Eradicating Helicobacter pylori infections may be a key treatment for Parkinson’s disease
October 20, 2018 - Breast Cancer as a Dynamic Disease
October 20, 2018 - University of Pittsburgh wins NSF grant for big data research to prevent complications from anesthesia
October 20, 2018 - Skin-to-skin contact may promote attachment between parents and preterm infants
October 20, 2018 - Recommendations Developed to Verify NGT Placement in Children
October 20, 2018 - Weight loss can be boosted fivefold thanks to novel mental imagery technique
October 20, 2018 - Children with autism are more likely to be overweight, obese
October 20, 2018 - Nurses making conscientious objections to ethically-relevant policies lack support
October 20, 2018 - Prion strain diversity may be greater than previously thought
October 20, 2018 - Antidepressant treatment may lead to improvements in sleep quality of patients with depression
October 20, 2018 - Study reports increased risk of death in children with inflammatory bowel disease
October 20, 2018 - Number of Autism Genes Now Tops 100
October 20, 2018 - Total diet replacement programmes are effective for treating obesity
October 20, 2018 - CLARIOstar used for fluorescence measurements on CSIRO’s purpose-built research vessel
October 20, 2018 - People with more copies of AMY1 gene digest starchy carbohydrates faster
October 20, 2018 - Case Comprehensive Cancer Center wins NIH grant to study health disparities
October 20, 2018 - Newly discovered compound shows potential for treating Parkinson’s disease
October 20, 2018 - High rate of non-adherence to hormonal therapy found among premenopausal early breast cancer patients
October 20, 2018 - Immunotherapy medicine found to be effective in treating uveitis
October 20, 2018 - The Pistoia Alliance Calls for Greater Collaboration to Realise Benefits of Innovation and Announces Winners of the 2018 President’s Startup Challenge
October 20, 2018 - Female internists consistently earn less than men
Intermittent Fasting: Another Fad Diet with Little Supporting Evidence

Intermittent Fasting: Another Fad Diet with Little Supporting Evidence

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

The world of diet and nutrition is both fascinating and challenging because everyone seems to have an opinion about it. We also readily accept the opinions of friends, both in real life and virtually, without much scrutiny. My patients regularly tell me about the all-natural juice cleanses, herbal supplements and the latest diet fads they hear about from friends at the neighborhood barbecue or their children visiting from out of state. They often start these diets after the initial recommendation or after reading a couple blog posts from random people that “Dr. Google” finds for them. When it comes to a pill or vaccine I recommend, suddenly they require detailed statistics and lengthy scientific explanations about the side effects, risks, and benefits. What would happen if we applied that same level of scrutiny to the intermittent fasting diet?

Intermittent fasting diets involve not eating or severely restricting food intake for certain hours of a day, or for certain days of the week. Common patterns include not eating past a certain hour in the evening, alternating days (one day eating normally, the other eating about 30% of normal) or the “5:2” method of eating normally for 5 days, then severely restricting/fasting for 2 days. Proponents point out that intermittent fasting has been used in ancient cultures from India, China, and many parts of Europe and is still practiced today all over the globe.

The claimed health benefits of intermittent fasting are numerous, ranging from weight loss, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease prevention to preventing or even treating cancer. However, most if not all of these claims are not ready for prime-time use because the science behind them is faulty or incomplete.

The biggest and most surprising failure of the intermittent fasting diet is in helping people lose weight. A study in JAMA Internal Medicine compared groups of people trying to lose weight eating a normal calorie-restricted diet versus alternate day fasting. They were studied for one year, which included a 6-month weight loss phase and a 6-month weight maintenance phase.

After 6 months and 12 months, the alternate day fasting group showed no additional weight loss compared to the traditional calorie restriction group. More people quit the alternate day fasting diet compared to simple calorie restriction because they couldn’t maintain it. Cardiovascular health markers like blood sugars, insulin levels, and cholesterol were no better in the alternate day fasting group either. In fact, LDL cholesterol levels were higher in the fasting group. Basically, people are able to eat more on non-fasting days to make up for any weight loss on fasting days. Additionally, fasting can trigger a starvation mode in the body that prevents weight loss and promotes higher blood sugar and cholesterol levels.

The claims that intermittent fasting can prevent cancer or starve a tumor are also based on shaky science. Most of the studies supporting these claims were done in mice or other animals. These often don’t translate to humans. The few human studies available have included very small numbers of patients. Furthermore, they don’t prove that intermittent fasting prevents cancer, only that it affects a blood marker that may be associated with cancer. One such marker is insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). High levels of IGF-1 have been correlated with prostate cancer and colon cancer. A study in mice in 2007 showed that intermittent fasting can lower levels of IGF-1. So it would make sense that intermittent fasting would prevent cancer or starve tumors, right? Not necessarily.

Consider a similar, alternate scenario of angiogenesis in cancer. Angiogenesis is the process of forming new blood vessels, which allows tumors to attract nutrients to grow and spread. Early studies of tumor angiogenesis from the 1970s-1990s were very exciting. It appeared that scientists had discovered the Achilles’s heel of all cancers. Several drugs were developed to inhibit angiogenesis. Despite these drugs effectively blocking angiogenesis and decades of research showing how important angiogenesis is in tumors, the drugs failed to treat most cancers and are only modestly effective in a few.

The human body is complex and sometimes even the most logical conclusions prove to be wrong as was the case with angiogenesis inhibitors. Similarly, assuming the effect of intermittent fasting on IGF-1 or other hormone levels will prevent cancer or starve tumors is inaccurate and potentially dangerous. Many of the claims about preventing Alzheimer’s, strokes, diabetes and aging follow the same logical fallacy.

The good news is, the short-term harms of intermittent fasting are minimal and largely theoretical. People taking medication to lower blood sugar like insulin or medications taken with food could have serious side effects from intermittent fasting. Vitamin and nutritional deficiencies could be worsened by intermittent fasting. Those with eating disorders or obsessive/compulsive tendencies also might have issues with intermittent fasting. Again, these risks are largely theoretical.

The long-term side effects of intermittent fasting are unknown as they have not been studied well in humans. The fact that many cultures have practiced intermittent fasting for millennia doesn’t prove its safety because for most of human history, people died before age 50 of infections and other currently preventable/treatable diseases.

One thing is clear: the intermittent fasting diet might be a good option for your pet mouse. The health benefits for humans remain to be determined.

2018-01-08T15:00:00-0500

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles