Breaking News
May 25, 2018 - New guidelines may help pathologists to more accurately classify and diagnose invasive melanoma
May 25, 2018 - Immune cells promote lung cancer metastases by forming clots in tumors, study finds
May 25, 2018 - Can Excess Weight in Toddlers Cause Brain Drain?
May 25, 2018 - Studying insight
May 25, 2018 - Researchers reveal potent new mechanism of action for treatment of IBD
May 25, 2018 - Study shows lack of follow-up care for patients with concussion
May 25, 2018 - Study establishes the importance of haploid cells
May 25, 2018 - Coveted BMJ award bestowed on The Clatterbridge Cancer Center
May 25, 2018 - AACN outlines evidence-based protocols and clinical strategies to manage alarms
May 25, 2018 - Origami inspires researchers to develop new solution for tissue regeneration
May 25, 2018 - Melorheostosis – Genetics Home Reference
May 25, 2018 - Non-addictive pain medication changing therapy for substance use disorders
May 25, 2018 - Delayed lactate measurements in sepsis patients increase risk of in-hospital death
May 25, 2018 - Researchers identify novel epigenetic mutations as cause of neurodevelopmental, congenital disorders
May 25, 2018 - UD researchers examine connection between DNA replication in HPV and cancer
May 25, 2018 - Researchers identify neurons that play key role in aggressive behavior
May 25, 2018 - Researchers discover unexpected chemosensor pathway for predator odor-evoked innate fear behaviors
May 25, 2018 - Nearly one in three people know someone addicted to opioids
May 25, 2018 - Research suggests link between faulty gene, alcohol, and heart failure
May 25, 2018 - New findings could help fine-tune treatment for cancer patients
May 25, 2018 - New cancer treatment approach targets specific sugar receptors
May 25, 2018 - Skin responsible for uptake of cancer-causing compounds during barbecuing than lungs
May 25, 2018 - Early-onset cannabis use linked to further drug abuse problems
May 25, 2018 - Covered California takes aim at hospital C-section rates
May 25, 2018 - FDA Approves Palynziq (pegvaliase-pqpz) for the Treatment of Adults with Phenylketonuria
May 25, 2018 - Arthritis Glossary
May 25, 2018 - Study links breast cancer to the body’s internal clock
May 25, 2018 - Strenuous exercise in teenage years may protect against height loss later in life
May 25, 2018 - FDA approves novel enzyme therapy for adults with rare and serious genetic disease
May 25, 2018 - New research project aims at developing effective interventions for kids with DLD
May 25, 2018 - Middlemen who save $$ on medicines — but maybe not for you
May 25, 2018 - Study sheds new light on sharp rise in fatal drug overdoses in recent years
May 25, 2018 - Students propose revision of listeriosis guidelines for safer pregnancy
May 25, 2018 - TNFi Exposure In Utero Does Not Up Serious Infection Risk
May 25, 2018 - Organization of cells in the inner ear enables the sense and sensitivity of hearing
May 25, 2018 - Yoga May Be Right Move Against Urinary Incontinence
May 25, 2018 - Drinking recommended amount of milk could protect obese children against metabolic syndrome
May 25, 2018 - New cytokine network can repair tissue damage in the intestine, study finds
May 25, 2018 - Lyme disease researcher dispels misconceptions about ticks and provides prevention tips
May 25, 2018 - Penn researchers find link between social media usage and underage drinking
May 25, 2018 - Unique nanotechnology method to simplify skin disease diagnosis
May 25, 2018 - Study reveals new protective mechanism for tumor cells in breast cancer
May 25, 2018 - FRAME Alternatives Laboratory chosen for major European liver research collaboration
May 25, 2018 - Study shows yogurt may dampen chronic inflammation linked to multiple diseases
May 25, 2018 - Invasive cancers that are born to be bad show detectable differences from harmless tumors
May 25, 2018 - Study identifies new mechanism involved in development of Lou Gehrig’s disease
May 25, 2018 - UAB professor receives award for malaria prevention study in pregnant women in Cameroon
May 25, 2018 - Study provides blueprint of how fruit flies can be used to screen potentially pathogenic human genes
May 25, 2018 - New drug-delivering nanoparticle could offer better way to treat brain tumors
May 25, 2018 - Kessler Foundation scientists compare two tests for assessing learning in individuals with MS
May 25, 2018 - Stroke Symptoms and Diagnosis (Beyond the Basics)
May 25, 2018 - Protein goes against the family to prevent cancer
May 25, 2018 - Drugmakers blamed for blocking generics have milked prices and cost U.S. billions
May 25, 2018 - Speakers announced for National Medicines Symposium 2018
May 25, 2018 - GSK Receives FDA Approval of Arnuity Ellipta for Asthma in Children From 5 Years of Age
May 25, 2018 - Pfizer settles kickback case related to copay assistance for $24m
May 25, 2018 - Nuclear pore functions are essential for T cell survival
May 25, 2018 - Study defines molecular basis to explain connection between mother’s nutrition and infant growth
May 24, 2018 - IHI hosts representatives to develop a national action plan for patient safety
May 24, 2018 - Zika detection breakthrough by University of Queensland
May 24, 2018 - FDA Alert: 95% Ethyl Alcohol Product by Ethanol Extraction: Recall
May 24, 2018 - New method allows scientists to study how HIV persists
May 24, 2018 - Study reveals rate of vertebral and non-vertebral fractures in children with leukemia
May 24, 2018 - Whey protein supplementation and physical activity aid women in improving body composition
May 24, 2018 - Seniors’ air pollution exposure linked to hospitalization for ARDS
May 24, 2018 - Home-based telehealth therapy program effective for stroke rehabilitation, shows study
May 24, 2018 - Addressing Parents’ HPV Vaccine Hesitancy Ups Vaccination Rates
May 24, 2018 - Opioid addiction treatment drug helps suppress HIV in former prisoners
May 24, 2018 - FDA warns against using teething remedies for babies
May 24, 2018 - Healthy lifestyle counseling program linked to reduced risk of developing cancers
May 24, 2018 - CU research sheds light on liver disease caused by intravenous nutrition
May 24, 2018 - Skin cream containing rapamycin reduces TSC-related facial tumors
May 24, 2018 - Suicide rates twice as high among black children finds new study
May 24, 2018 - Researchers find new method to treat severe asthma
May 24, 2018 - Scientists report new strategy for fighting bacteria
May 24, 2018 - South Asians living in the United States more likely to die of heart disease and stroke
May 24, 2018 - Health Tip: Why Get a Biopsy
May 24, 2018 - Metabolic Syndrome Prevalence by Race/Ethnicity and Sex in the United States, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1988–2012
May 24, 2018 - Motivation to move may start with being mindful
May 24, 2018 - Advanced genetics study of TB bacteria uncovers virulent ‘Beijing lineage’ strain among young adults
Young doctors struggle to learn robotic surgery – so they are practicing in the shadows

Young doctors struggle to learn robotic surgery – so they are practicing in the shadows

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Artificial intelligence and robotics spell massive changes to the world of work. These technologies can automate new tasks, and we are making more of them, faster, better and cheaper than ever before.

Surgery was early to the robotics party: Over a third of U.S. hospitals have at least one surgical robot. Such robots have been in widespread use by a growing variety of surgical disciplines, including urology and gynecology, for over a decade. That means the technology has been around for least two generations of surgeons and surgical staff.

I studied robotic surgery for over two years to understand how surgeons are adapting. I observed hundreds of robotic and “traditional” procedures at five hospitals and interviewed surgeons and surgical trainees at another 13 hospitals around the country. I found that robotic surgery disrupted approved approaches surgical training. Only a minority of residents found effective alternatives.

Like the surgeons I studied, we’re all going to have to adapt to AI and robotics. Old hands and new recruits will have to learn new ways to do their jobs, whether in construction, lawyering, retail, finance, warfare or childcare – no one is immune. How will we do this? And what will happen when we try?

A shift in surgery

In my new paper, published January 8, I specifically focus on how surgical trainees, known as residents, learned to use the 800-pound gorilla: Intuitive Surgical’s da Vinci surgical system. This is a four-armed robot that holds sticklike surgical instruments, controlled by a surgeon sitting at a console 15 or so feet away from the patient.

Robotic surgery presented a radically different work scenario for residents. In traditional (open) surgery, the senior surgeon literally couldn’t do most of the work without constant hands-in-the-patient cooperation from the resident. So residents could learn by sticking to strong “see one, do one, teach one” norms for surgical training.

This broke down in robotic surgery. Residents were stuck either “sucking” at the bedside – using a laparoscopic tool to remove smoke and fluids from the patient – or sitting in a second trainee console, watching the surgical action and waiting for a chance to operate.

In either case, surgeons didn’t need residents’ help, so they granted residents a lot less practice operating than they did in open procedures. The practice residents did get was lower-quality because surgeons “helicopter taught” – giving frequent and very public feedback to residents at the console and intermittently taking control of the robot away from them.

As one resident said: “If you’re on the robot and [control is] taken away, it’s completely taken away and you’re just left to think about exactly what you did wrong, like a kid sitting in the corner with a dunce cap. Whereas in open surgery, you’re still working.”

Shadow learning

Very few residents overcame these barriers to effectively learn how to perform this kind of surgery. The rest struggled – yet all were legally and professionally empowered to perform robotic surgeries when they finished their residencies.

Successful learners made progress through three norm-bending practices. Some focused on robotic surgery in the midst of medical school at the expense of generalist medical training. Others practiced extensively via simulators and watched recorded surgeries on YouTube when learning in real procedures was prized. Many learned through undersupervised struggle – performing robotic surgical work close to the edge of their capacity with little expert supervision.

Put together, I called these practices “shadow learning,” because they ran counter to norms and residents engaged in them out of the limelight. Also, none of this was openly discussed, let alone punished or forbidden.

Shadow learning came at a serious cost to successful residents, their peers and their profession. Shadow learners became hyperspecialized in robotic surgery, but most were destined for jobs that required generalist skills. They learned at the expense of their struggling peers, because they got more “console time” when senior surgeons saw they could operate well. The profession has been slow to adapt to all this practically invisible trouble. And these dynamics have restricted the supply of expert robotic surgeons.

As one senior surgeon told me, robotics has had an “opposite effect” on learning. Surgeons from top programs are graduating without sufficient skill with robotic tools, he said. “I mean these guys can’t do it. They haven’t had any experience doing it. They watched it happen. Watching a movie doesn’t make you an actor, you know what I’m saying?”

The working world

These insights are relevant for surgery, but can also help us all think more clearly about the implications of AI and robotics for the broader world of work. Businesses are buying robots and AI technologies at a breakneck pace, based on the promise of improved productivity and the threat of being left behind.

Early on, journalists, social scientists and politicians focused on how these technologies would destroy or create jobs. These are important issues, but the global conversation has recently turned to a much bigger one: job change. According to one analysis from McKinsey, 30 percent of the tasks in the average U.S. job could soon be profitably automated.

It’s often costly – in dollars, time and errors – to allow trainees to work with experts. In our quest for productivity, we are deploying many technologies and techniques that make trainee involvement optional. Wherever we do this, shadow learning may become more prevalent, with similar, troubling implications: a shrinking, hyperspecialized minority; a majority that is losing the skill to do the work effectively; and organizations that don’t know how learning is actually happening.

If we’re not careful, we may unwittingly improve our way out of the skill we need to meet the needs of a changing world.


Explore further:
New system proposed for logging physician experience in robotic surgeries

Provided by:
The Conversation

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles