Breaking News
June 22, 2018 - Oxidative stress can be used against tumors to treat cancer
June 22, 2018 - Simple, cost-effective test may help improve early diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment
June 22, 2018 - New guide published to help battle fatal disease caused by kissing bugs
June 22, 2018 - Stigma Adds to Burden of Type 1 Diabetes
June 22, 2018 - In retinoblastoma survivors, oculo-visual issues tied to QoL
June 22, 2018 - Most adults with allergies do not use prescribed epinephrine even in emergency situations
June 22, 2018 - Study provides clues to how cancer cells develop resistance to chemotherapies
June 22, 2018 - New consensus paper serves as basis for uniform medical management of DSD
June 22, 2018 - Researchers work to identify areas of the brain that help us wake up
June 22, 2018 - Alcohol hangovers more significant and costly than people realize, shows research
June 22, 2018 - Targeting cells involved in blood vessel formation could hinder brain tumor growth
June 22, 2018 - Young cancer survivors need more support as they feel dissatisfied with their sexuality
June 22, 2018 - Unusual cell-to-cell communication in glioblastoma promotes aggressiveness and therapy resistance
June 22, 2018 - Turning A Phage – Drug Discovery Today
June 22, 2018 - World-first study links birth interventions and long-term childhood illness
June 22, 2018 - Improving the quality of biomedical research samples
June 22, 2018 - Researchers identify cerebral palsy using AI and DNA sequencing
June 22, 2018 - Administering nitric oxide gas after heart surgery may decrease risk of kidney problems
June 22, 2018 - Measuring levels of ethyl sulphate in hair can help assess alcohol consumption
June 22, 2018 - Researchers develop robot bloodhound that can rapidly detect odors on the ground
June 22, 2018 - AAA doses first patients in two clinical studies with PSMA-R2 for prostate cancer
June 22, 2018 - UC San Diego launches new bacteriophage therapy center
June 22, 2018 - New review outlines current state of sex-sensitive issues linked to heart failure drugs
June 22, 2018 - Pelvic pain a major issue for women nearing mid-life, research reveals
June 22, 2018 - Researchers develop reliable DNA barcodes for biomedical research
June 22, 2018 - New risk-prediction model may help identify diabetic patients at high risk of pancreatic cancer
June 22, 2018 - Study reveals how mTORC1-driven changes in crowding could influence major diseases
June 22, 2018 - Researchers uncover new therapeutic opportunity in the treatment of malignant melanoma
June 22, 2018 - UC Riverside researcher receives grants to advance cancer, ALS research
June 22, 2018 - Radiation therapy alone may be enough to treat older, sicker patients with anal cancers
June 22, 2018 - Technical report describes how to make accurate particle size measurements on carbon black samples
June 22, 2018 - Nocdurna (desmopressin acetate) Approved by FDA as First Sublingual Tablet to Treat Nocturia due to Nocturnal Polyuria
June 22, 2018 - Neuroscientists locate neurons in the brain that respond when a visual target is found
June 22, 2018 - First human Keystone virus infection reported
June 22, 2018 - New study reveals how ‘good’ bacteria help in regulating our metabolism
June 22, 2018 - Osteopathic manual therapy affecting the diaphragm improves chronic low back pain
June 22, 2018 - Researchers create revolutionary model to study pulmonary diseases
June 22, 2018 - Diagnosing Heart Disease Using AI
June 22, 2018 - Increasing biodefense risks posed by synthetic biology
June 22, 2018 - Many Women Report Vasomotor Symptoms in Their 60s
June 22, 2018 - Rare mutation of gene carried by Quebec family gives insight into how the brain is wired
June 22, 2018 - Chemists find new way to make enzymes do a non-natural reaction
June 22, 2018 - Summer is good time to check for signs of skin cancer
June 22, 2018 - Innovative method can help identify patients with spastic cerebral palsy
June 22, 2018 - Exercise alters characteristics of blood to reduce inflammation in obese people
June 22, 2018 - Researchers examine complications across different types of breast reconstructive surgeries
June 22, 2018 - Rhesus macaque model could be useful to test therapies for congenital Zika virus syndrome
June 22, 2018 - AHA: New Insights Into Sickle Cell and Stroke Risk
June 22, 2018 - Doctors prescribe opioids at high rates to those at increased overdose risk
June 22, 2018 - Reduction in US cigarette smoking rates
June 22, 2018 - Preconception binge drinking may have negative effect on future offspring
June 22, 2018 - FDA expands approval of novel diabetes management device to include younger pediatric patients
June 22, 2018 - Researchers confirm weight loss benefits of the 16:8 diet
June 22, 2018 - FDA approves Eversense CGM system for use in adults with diabetes
June 22, 2018 - State opioid monitoring programs are not created equal
June 22, 2018 - Autistic teens who are bullied have higher rates of depression
June 22, 2018 - Penn Medicine team launches universal stroke awareness program
June 22, 2018 - Scientists discover the molecular trigger of necroptosis
June 22, 2018 - Researchers report unusually high levels of herpesvirus in the brains of people with Alzheimer’s disease
June 22, 2018 - Theoretical models predict how juveniles evolve to be more susceptible than adults to infection
June 22, 2018 - USC study reveals how the cell launches emergency response to repair damaged DNA
June 22, 2018 - $1.9 million grant aims to enhance behavioral health services in community-based settings
June 22, 2018 - New 3D imaging technique could improve arthritis treatment
June 22, 2018 - Cytokinetics Announces Data From Phase 2 Clinical Study of Reldesemtiv in Patients With Spinal Muscular Atrophy
June 22, 2018 - Polarized cells give the heart its fully developed form
June 21, 2018 - Stem cells appear to help fight obesity in animal models
June 21, 2018 - Harnessing Pediatric Cancer Genomic Data in the Cloud
June 21, 2018 - Training nursing students with cost-effective 3D-printed task trainers
June 21, 2018 - Study provides insight into how planned and spontaneous movements are processed in the brain
June 21, 2018 - Suicide Prevention | SAMHSA – Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration
June 21, 2018 - From designer microbes to stem cells, researchers are investigating new strategies to treat bowel disease
June 21, 2018 - Study suggests state-of-the-art genomic testing for routine autopsy of stillbirths
June 21, 2018 - Christiana Care Health System opens first Epilepsy Monitoring Unit in Delaware
June 21, 2018 - CDC: Obesity Prevalence Higher in Non-Metropolitan Counties
June 21, 2018 - Youths Treated for Non-Suicidal Self Harm at Increased Risk of Suicide Within a Year
June 21, 2018 - WVU researchers increase colorectal cancer screening rates in West Virginia
June 21, 2018 - Pediatric kidney recipients often have subclinical inflammation
June 21, 2018 - OHSU Knight Cancer Institute Director wins 2018 Tang Prize in Biopharmaceutical Science
June 21, 2018 - Researchers study broader effects of neonics on wildlife
June 21, 2018 - Study provides new insight on how antibiotics affect the gut microbiome
To improve self-control, call weight loss what it is: Difficult

To improve self-control, call weight loss what it is: Difficult

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print
Credit: Drexel University

To reach your New Year’s fitness goals, a bit of reverse psychology might be in order. Telling people that weight loss is extremely challenging—rather than imparting a “You can do it!” mantra—motivated them to shed more weight, according to a new study by psychologists at Drexel University. However, the strategy did not compel participants to achieve the goal for which it was originally designed: to modify or replace many of the unhealthy foods in their homes.

The study’s findings, published this week in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, have conflicting implications, says Michael Lowe, PhD, a professor at Drexel’s College of Arts and Sciences.

“On one hand, giving overweight people a realistic sense of the dilemma that they are in and the powerful forces they are up against—including a genetic predisposition toward obesity and an increased susceptibility to many food cues in the environment—may actually promote cognitive restraint over their eating in the short-term,” Lowe said. “But, on the other hand, this message did not motivate participants to make numerous changes to the foods they surround themselves with.”

Lowe and a team of researchers originally set out to determine the effectiveness of three weight loss interventions: behavior therapy, behavior therapy plus meal replacements, or a condition focused on getting people to change foods in their home food environments. They enrolled 262 overweight and obese individuals and assigned them to one of the three methods, while tracking their weight over a three-year period.

Behavior therapy—the current “gold standard” in weight loss treatment—involves group support, regular weigh-ins, exercise, explicit goal setting and monitoring food intake, while meal replacement treatment replaces breakfast and lunch with calorie-controlled shakes or nutrition bars.

Behavior therapy is aimed at bolstering someone’s internal sense of self-regulation over food intake and exercise. But research has shown that increases in self-control are not sustainable, and lost weight is almost always regained. The powerful lure of foods high in fat, sugar and salt has been well-documented, and existing treatments do not do enough to ensure that foods kept in the home are permanently changed in ways that make self-control more feasible, according to Lowe.

“You can’t just give advice,” he said. “You have to work with people to eliminate and substitute very specific foods, and teach them to prepare food differently.”

That’s why his research team hypothesized that modifying the home food environment (or HFE) would be the most effective strategy for losing and maintaining weight loss. Participants in this group were given homework assignments to identify and make numerous changes to specific foods that were still satisfying but less calorically damaging.

“Asking people to make healthy decisions, when there are thousands of food choices available, is both emotionally challenging and also complicated,” Lowe said. “HFE treatment is really about mechanically trying to ensure that these changes are made, so the level of chronic temptation generated by foods in their homes is reduced.”

Most importantly, the research team repeatedly reminded the HFE group about the challenges associated with weight loss and maintenance. In doing this, the researchers aimed to acknowledge the participants’ vulnerability to overconsume favorite foods.

“We said, ‘It’s impressive and encouraging that you are taking this step to improve your weight and health, but we need to help you understand the daunting challenges you’re facing.’ The reason we did this was not to discourage them, but to give them a more realistic sense of how crucial it is for them to make lasting changes in their parts of the food environment that they could control,” Lowe said.

People struggling with their weight are likely to hold themselves responsible, even though a number of internal (heredity, for example) and external (fast food restaurants) forces are at play and beyond their control, Lowe said. The researchers suggested that by making multiple changes to their food environment, participants would be reducing the need to perpetually exercise self-control to maintain the weight they lost.

In addition to measuring the participants’ weights during six assessment sessions over three years, the researchers also assessed conditions such as binge eating, quality of life, cognitive restraint and food cravings by using questionnaires and statistical analysis.

At the end of the three-year study period, the researchers found that those in the HFE group lost more weight than those in the behavior therapy group. However, the differential in weight loss was modest, and all participants showed the familiar trend toward weight regain.

“We failed to get them to translate our warnings into the kind of actions we were trying to get them to take,” Lowe said.

The warnings did, however, have a positive—though unanticipated—effect. Cognitive restraint—defined by a participant’s ability to actively make healthy choices and measured with mediation analysis—showed the longest, most prolonged increase in the HFE participants, when compared to the other two treatment groups.

This suggests that the researchers’ rhetoric about the difficulties of sustaining weight loss may have actually caused the participants in the HFE group to “push back” against this message and increase their vigilance over their eating, Lowe said.

“That is, by questioning the usefulness of building self-control skills, the HFE treatment may have bolstered the very capacity it was meant to downplay—stronger self-control with regard to food,” the study authors write.

Though surprising, these results have potentially clinically-useful implications. By emphasizing the many factors that make lasting weight loss so difficult, it may help motivate individuals to mentally and behaviorally cope with these factors, according to Lowe.

“Rather than acting as cheerleaders giving facile encouragement, leaders of weight loss groups might serve their clients better by providing a more sobering description of the challenges participants face,” Lowe explained.

However, since the participants in the HFE condition did not make greater changes to their home food environment, future studies should examine how to better improve and monitor this weight loss intervention, such as sending dieticians or other practitioners directly to clients’ homes for periodic visits.

For Lowe, the study reinforces the challenging reality for those seeking to maintain weight loss—and makes a strong case for policies (such as Philadelphia’s beverage tax) that focus on preventing, rather than treating, the problem of obesity in the United States.

“Once these conditions develop and you are continuing to live in the same obesogenic environment, it is unrealistic to expect that many people will be able to sustain a large weight loss,” he said. “Society ultimately needs to prevent these unhealthy weight gains before they occur.”


Explore further:
Shedding consistent pounds each week linked to long-term weight loss

More information:
Michael R Lowe et al, Evaluation of meal replacements and a home food environment intervention for long-term weight loss: a randomized controlled trial, The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2018). DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/nqx005

Journal reference:
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition

Provided by:
Drexel University

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles