Breaking News
July 15, 2018 - Parents who had severe trauma, stresses in childhood more likely to have kids with behavioral health problems
July 15, 2018 - At colloquium, a range of views on value of predictive algorithms | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Pittcon invites oral and poster presentations for 2019 Technical Program
July 15, 2018 - Virtual reality could offer psychotherapy for fear of heights, study shows
July 15, 2018 - Retooled vaccine raises hopes as a lower-cost treatment for Type 1 diabetes
July 15, 2018 - Kolon TissueGene To Start US Phase III Clinical Trial For Invossa
July 15, 2018 - Study finds prenatal marijuana use can affect infant size, behavior
July 15, 2018 - Howard Chang named HHMI investigator | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Study shows tailored mental health services improve wellbeing of emerging adults
July 15, 2018 - A bright future might help teens steer clear of violence
July 15, 2018 - Stanford Medicine magazine explores the art, science of listening and hearing | News Center
July 15, 2018 - New study tracks how the brain turns simple sensory inputs into meaningful categories
July 15, 2018 - Deadlier subtype of metastatic prostate cancer found to be common than previously thought
July 15, 2018 - UZH scientists identify enzyme that controls cell division
July 15, 2018 - Unhealthy Food Behaviors May Signal Eating Disorder in Teen
July 15, 2018 - Study raises doubts on a previous theory of Parkinson’s disease
July 15, 2018 - Grant awarded to study whether stem cells can treat urinary incontinence | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Imaging techniques may help assess immune system recovery in HIV patients
July 15, 2018 - Machine-learning may aid in diagnosis and treatment of mental health disorders
July 15, 2018 - ‘Skin Cancer, Take A Hike!’ program promotes sun safety and skin cancer awareness
July 15, 2018 - Blink Health announces lowest prices for generic prescriptions through Blue Eagle Health
July 15, 2018 - New drug strategy can alleviate multiple behavioral, cellular deficiencies in FXS mouse model
July 15, 2018 - Georgia State professor receives federal grant to study virus similar to Ebola virus
July 15, 2018 - Quitting Smoking? Even a Little Exercise Can Help You Stay Slim
July 15, 2018 - DBS treatment may slow the progression of Parkinson’s tremor in early-stage patients
July 15, 2018 - 5 Questions: Luby on virus with potential to cause global pandemic | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Corn loses its cancer-fighting phenolic acids when processed into cornflakes
July 15, 2018 - Study uncovers possible link between iron loading, alcohol intake and mortality
July 15, 2018 - Molecular insights of NagA enzyme could help combat TB
July 15, 2018 - The Facts on Tampons—and How to Use Them Safely
July 15, 2018 - Normalisation of ‘plus-size’ risks hidden danger of obesity, study finds
July 15, 2018 - $2.5 million award to support physician-scientist training | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Aeras announces publication of Phase 2 results of two TB vaccines
July 15, 2018 - Public to set research priorities in field of ethnic inequalities and severe mental illness
July 15, 2018 - Eisai and Biogen Announce Positive Topline Results of the Final Analysis for BAN2401 at 18 Months
July 15, 2018 - U.S. obesity rates rising again
July 15, 2018 - Millions could have incorrect statin, aspirin and blood pressure prescriptions | News Center
July 15, 2018 - Researchers identify factors associated with cell phone-related distracted driving in parents
July 15, 2018 - Bioethicists suggest ethical considerations for forensic use of genetic data
July 15, 2018 - Most clinical trial participants find benefits of sharing personal data outweigh risks, Stanford study finds | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Researchers solve protein puzzle that paves way for new cancer therapies
July 14, 2018 - Blood telomeres can help predict risk of disease worsening or death in COPD patients
July 14, 2018 - CDC: Nearly One-Third of Injury Deaths Occur at Home
July 14, 2018 - Injectable electronics offer powerful new tool in understanding how retinal cells work
July 14, 2018 - Human blood cells transformed into functional neurons | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Podcast: KHN’s ‘What the Health?’ ACA under fire. Again.
July 14, 2018 - Small device with motion sensors can predict older adults’ risk of falling
July 14, 2018 - Neurological Fallout From Ebola Infection Worse Than Thought
July 14, 2018 - Screening for impaired vision in older adults: New Canadian guideline
July 14, 2018 - Blood test for pregnant women can predict premature birth, Stanford-led study reports | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Study uncovers process that neutralizes tumor cells
July 14, 2018 - Four-protein biomarker blood test improves lung cancer risk assessment for smokers
July 14, 2018 - Researchers develop novel approach to bridge gap in cell-free systems
July 14, 2018 - Research reveals new gears in the circadian clock
July 14, 2018 - Researchers assess role of physician in preventing intimate partner violence perpetration
July 14, 2018 - Two diabetes medications don’t slow progression of type 2 diabetes in youth
July 14, 2018 - New clues to restoring fertility in women with disabling ovary disorder
July 14, 2018 - Compound in citrus oil could reduce dry mouth in head, neck cancer patients | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Streck ARM-D Kits detect more antibiotic resistance than comparable tests
July 14, 2018 - Study finds wide variations in follow-up imaging for women with non-metastatic breast cancer
July 14, 2018 - FDA expands its support for states to implement FSMA Produce Safety Rule
July 14, 2018 - CTI BioPharma Announces the Continuation without Modification of PAC203 Phase 2 Study of Pacritinib in Patients with Myelofibrosis Previously Treated with Ruxolitinib
July 14, 2018 - First-hand accounts of premature baby loss inspires new resource
July 14, 2018 - Study identifies cellular ‘death code’ | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Federal judge enters consent decree against Minnesota dairy farm for selling adulterated meat
July 14, 2018 - New web-based game motivates people to exercise more
July 14, 2018 - Calcium electrotransfer could be used to target cancer cells, study finds
July 14, 2018 - Researchers identify new region in mouse brain that affects appetite and body weight
July 14, 2018 - Repeated testing produces ‘practice effect’ that obscures true cognitive decline
July 14, 2018 - Amgen And UCB Resubmit Biologics License Application (BLA) For Evenity (romosozumab) To The US FDA
July 14, 2018 - New research detects brain cell that improves learning
July 14, 2018 - Spirit, Inspiring Change award winners announced | News Center
July 14, 2018 - Opioid patients face several barriers to treatment, study finds
July 14, 2018 - Black adults more likely to develop high blood pressure by age of 55
July 14, 2018 - Insurers fall short in catching and reporting Medicaid fraud, inspectors find
July 14, 2018 - Scientists identify structural and functional differences in human immune-surveillance protein
July 14, 2018 - FDA Approves TPOXX (tecovirimat) as the First Drug for the Treatment of Smallpox
July 14, 2018 - Visual perceptual skills are updated by process similar to memory reconsolidation, study finds
July 14, 2018 - Big Data in Precision Health focuses on how to make technology work for patient care | News Center
July 14, 2018 - New technique measures how well cancer drugs reach their targets
JAMA editorial on ECG screening and cardiac risks

JAMA editorial on ECG screening and cardiac risks

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Robert J. Myerburg, M.D., professor of medicine and physiology, and the American Heart Association Chair in Cardiovascular Research at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, contributed an editorial to the Journal of the American Medical Association placing in perspective some of the conclusions in new recommendations from the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) regarding the use of electrocardiogram screening for cardiovascular disease risk.

The USPSTF is an independent, volunteer panel of national experts in prevention and evidence-based medicine. Its recommendations statement was accompanied by a separate evidence report. The two articles and Myerburg’s editorial will be published online at 11 a.m. on June 12. The USPSTF statement recommends against rest and exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) screening of asymptomatic adults at low risk for cardiovascular disease events, defined by cardiovascular risk profiles, because of the unlikelihood of it resulting in any improvement in health outcomes. It further states that current evidence is insufficient to assess the balance of benefits and harms associated with testing intermediate- and high-risk patients.

Myerburg agrees in part with the recommendation for low-risk asymptomatic patients, but points out that statistics derived from large population groups do not necessarily apply to individual patients. Furthermore there is a difference between screening based on routine ECGs at the time of annual preventive care visits, and a small number of repeat ECGs recorded periodically.

“It is not yet clear whether there is value to a single random resting ECG retained in the records of middle-aged adult patients, which may serve as a baseline for comparison when these patients present with nonspecific symptoms at a later time,” he wrote in his editorial. For higher-risk patients, he believes clinicians should be focusing more on the power of “treatable risk factors” such as diabetes, hyperlipidemia, cigarette smoking, and hypertension, as well as the contribution of family history. Based on the USPSTF statement, when and how often to obtain screening ECG tests should be based on the magnitude of individual risk score and the physician’s clinical judgement.

“The problem of individual risk prediction remains a major challenge in clinical practice,” said Myerburg. “In many of the studies estimating population risk, the effect size associated with statistically significant risk profiling is insufficient to make reliable statements about individual risk. This limitation also remains a challenge for the future.”

As for USPSTF’s concern about risk from ECG testing itself, such as adverse outcomes from unnecessary catheter interventions, “there is less concern about this as a risk-vs.-benefit question as physicians are educated about when to intervene,” said Myerburg. “The diagnostic test is of less concern. Therefore, this issue is largely related to education regarding the need for intervention, as opposed to the resting or exercise ECGs themselves.”

Another benefit of testing is the potential discovery of inherited diseases and conditions, such as a genetic trait known as long QT interval syndrome, which is linked to sudden cardiac arrest and the structural inherited diseases such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

“Data from Italy suggest that patients with unrecognized or untreated long QT interval syndrome have a 13 percent mortality rate between infancy and age 40 years,” he said. “Early recognition and effective therapies can have favorable impacts, and a single screening ECG may be sufficient.”

Finally, Myerburg suggests testing special populations, such as competitive athletes undergoing pre-participation evaluations.

“This is a controversial area in the United States, although generally accepted elsewhere,” he said. “It is similar to the genetic disorders, in that the probability of identification of disease is low because of the prevalence rates, but the potential for adding years of quality life by prevention is large.”

Myerburg points out the need for further research.

“As new knowledge about the subtleties of risk and risk prediction emerge from future research, reevaluation of the potential value of these procedures may lead to appropriate reclassification of risk,” he said. “The sciences contributing to medical practice are dynamic, and today’s valid conclusions may be modified by future information.”


Explore further:
USPSTF reviews use of ECG for preventing A-fib, CVD events

Journal reference:
Journal of the American Medical Association

Provided by:
University of Miami Leonard M. Miller School of Medicine

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles