Breaking News
March 18, 2019 - Taking painkillers during pregnancy is not responsible for asthma risk in children, study shows
March 18, 2019 - Prediagnosis Psychiatric Care Linked to Worse Cancer Mortality
March 18, 2019 - Paris hospital halts stool study after donor deluge
March 18, 2019 - Partial oral antibiotic therapy shows efficacy and safety in patients with infectious endocarditis
March 18, 2019 - Olympus improves access to science education through BioBus collaboration
March 18, 2019 - Depression screening does not improve quality of life in heart attack patients
March 18, 2019 - Echocardiography may aid in patient selection for TMVR
March 18, 2019 - Are ‘Inactive’ Ingredients in Your Drugs Really So Harmless?
March 18, 2019 - Scientists tackle rare retinal disease in unique research project
March 18, 2019 - Death By A Thousand Clicks
March 18, 2019 - Absorbable, antibiotic-eluting envelope can reduce rate of cardiac device infections
March 18, 2019 - Hormonal treatment associated with depression in men with prostate cancer
March 18, 2019 - Porvair Sciences launches reinforced 96-well deep round microplate
March 18, 2019 - Simplified catheter ablation could slash waiting lists for atrial fibrillation patients
March 18, 2019 - BFR therapy as part of rehabilitation following ACL surgery may slow bone loss
March 18, 2019 - A human model to test implants for cataract surgery
March 18, 2019 - New risk adjustment model could reduce financial penalty for safety net hospitals
March 18, 2019 - NHS cancer patients’ wait to start treatment worrying
March 18, 2019 - Inventiva Announces Results from Phase IIb Clinical Trial with Lanifibranor in Systemic Sclerosis
March 18, 2019 - Cologuard
March 18, 2019 - Researchers find evidence of prenatal environment tuning genomic imprinting
March 18, 2019 - Dolomite Bio launches novel Nadia product family for single-cell research
March 18, 2019 - Intellipharmaceutics Announces Resubmission of New Drug Application to the U.S. FDA for its Oxycodone ER
March 18, 2019 - Excessive gestational weight gain tied to maternal morbidity
March 18, 2019 - RCEM issues position statement on metrics to supplement four-hour standard target
March 17, 2019 - Noncontrast Brain MRI Effective for Monitoring Multiple Sclerosis
March 17, 2019 - Brain region plays key role in regulation of parenting behavior, study finds
March 17, 2019 - Natural speed limit on DNA replication sets pace for life’s first steps
March 17, 2019 - New research reveals overlooked impact of herbicide glyphosate on the environment
March 17, 2019 - Molecular patterns could help predict relapse risk in breast cancer patients
March 17, 2019 - Study confirms sensitivity of microbiological cultures for detecting cholera
March 17, 2019 - Scientists Spot Clues to Predicting Breast Cancer’s Return
March 17, 2019 - Scientists identify gene that keeps PTSD-like behavior at bay in female mice
March 17, 2019 - New method would allow doctors to detect earliest stages of cancers in the lymph nodes
March 17, 2019 - Cholesterol protein discovery raises hope for smarter drugs
March 17, 2019 - New insect medium delivers high viable cell density growth and protein yield
March 17, 2019 - Opioid crisis brings concerns about heart dangers
March 17, 2019 - Resistance Training May Prevent Type 2 Diabetes Progression
March 17, 2019 - Bioluminescence sensors make new approaches to drug discovery possible
March 17, 2019 - New FDA Rules Aim to Keep Kids From Flavored E-Cigarettes
March 17, 2019 - Vitamin B3 analogue boosts production of blood cells
March 17, 2019 - Government cuts to stop smoking services have detrimental impact on public health
March 17, 2019 - Common tool to assess potential adoptive parents lags behind societal changes
March 17, 2019 - Patients’ own cells could be the key to treating Crohn’s disease
March 17, 2019 - Diagnostic delays common in inflammatory bowel disease
March 17, 2019 - Study uncovers dramatic differences in the brains of Hispanics with dementia
March 17, 2019 - Study describes epigenetic loss that changes how cells obtain energy from cancer
March 16, 2019 - Active Bathing in Non-ICU Setting Does Not Cut Infections
March 16, 2019 - How the immune system maintains a healthy gut microbiota
March 16, 2019 - Bacteria ‘trap’ could help in the fight against antimicrobial resistance
March 16, 2019 - Hospital work environment associated with all EHR usability outcomes
March 16, 2019 - Study unravels mystery behind how the brain encodes time when forming long-term memories
March 16, 2019 - Light physical activity may lower risk of cardiovascular disease in older women
March 16, 2019 - USP15 enzyme could potentially lead to new treatments for breast, pancreatic cancer
March 16, 2019 - After Chinese Infant Gene-Editing Scandal, U.S. Health Officials Join Call for a Ban
March 16, 2019 - PACS1 syndrome – Genetics Home Reference
March 16, 2019 - Researchers discover an unexpected organization of antimicrobial molecules that amplifies immune response
March 16, 2019 - With New Study, Era of Open-Heart Surgery for Aortic Stenosis May be Ending
March 16, 2019 - Dolomite Bio introduces high throughput sNuc-Seq protocol for its Nadia Instrument
March 16, 2019 - New course prepares materials scientists for biomedical testing
March 16, 2019 - Finding clues to a functional HIV cure
March 16, 2019 - People with chronic periodontitis have higher risk for dementia
March 16, 2019 - Few heart care recommendations are based on rigorous study
March 16, 2019 - Colorectal cancer diagnosed at early age is distinct from that in older patients
March 16, 2019 - Researchers use MRI and AI techniques at birth to predict cognitive development at age 2
March 16, 2019 - Discarding information from the brain linked to more mental effort, finds study
March 16, 2019 - OTA International supplement provides current snapshot and forward look at global trauma systems
March 16, 2019 - NIH trial to track outcomes of liver transplantation from HIV+ donors to HIV+ recipients
March 16, 2019 - Apple Heart Study shows how wearable technology can help detect heart problem
March 16, 2019 - Researchers determine factors that cause stress development in the human body
March 16, 2019 - Elderly Men Undertreated for Osteoporosis
March 16, 2019 - People with chronic pain are coping with the help of Pinterest, new study reveals
March 16, 2019 - New study could reveal the complex interaction between languages and human beings who use them
March 16, 2019 - Tufts engineers develop new tool to identify metabolic signatures linked to disease
March 16, 2019 - New proteomics-based test could aid in early detection of ovarian cancer
March 16, 2019 - New research opens possibility of using sperm taken from testicles to overcome infertility
March 16, 2019 - Scientists find new proof that narcolepsy is an autoimmune disease
March 16, 2019 - FDA OKs a New Generic of the Blood Pressure Drug Valsartan to Ease Shortage Due to Recalls
March 16, 2019 - Eliminating smoking and obesity could affect racial health disparities
March 16, 2019 - Wearable tracking device achieves higher accuracy in position tracking using thermal sensors
Sending parents letters to fight childhood obesity doesn’t work

Sending parents letters to fight childhood obesity doesn’t work

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print
Not impressed. Credit: Shutterstock

Around this time every year, the height and weight of over 95% of children in the first and final years of primary school in England are measured as part of the National Child Measurement Programme (NCMP). With childhood obesity levels rising, this data set is put to use to identify and support parents whose children are at risk.

In most local authorities, carefully worded letters are sent home to parents whose children are overweight, making them aware of this and offering support to bring about change. But only a handful of parents take up offers of support, and many have publicly expressed the anger and distress they feel on receiving feedback that their child is overweight. Indeed, some health experts have called for an overhaul of the so-called “fat letters”.

As a researcher who has been working with public health teams and Public Health England to try and improve the feedback process and impact on parents, I know it can be tempting to dismiss some parents’ negative reactions as rare exceptions, or perceive them as a temporary distress that parents need to go through before accepting the truth about their child.

But after 12 years, one thing has become clear: the way we are using the NCMP data is alienating, rather than engaging, the families we really want to reach – so perhaps it’s public health professionals, and not parents, who need to change.

Why doesn’t it work?

Parents raise many very reasonable objections to feedback that their child is overweight. For example, some argue that their child looks normal (which may be true, now that one in three ten- to 11-year-olds are overweight).

Others say that their child has started puberty, so should be judged by different criteria. Again, this may be true; recent analysis suggests that up to 32% of early-maturing ten- to 11-year-old girls considered overweight according to their chronological age would not be considered overweight if their level of maturity were taken into account.

Parents also report real fears that talking to children about being overweight could harm their self-esteem and well-being, and ultimately lead to eating disorders. While there’s no evidence that one leads to the other, discussions with children about losing weight are associated with poorer well-being.

Parents also lack confidence that they are capable of making a difference, especially if they have struggled with their own weight in the past. Where this is the case, parents don’t consider taking action to be worth the potential risks to their child’s well-being.

These objections raise some genuine challenges, but don’t fully explain why some parents might consider these arguments more compelling than factual information about their child’s health. At the root of this problem is the stigma attached to obesity and overweight people.

Decades of research shows that the public and health professionals alike have an unconscious bias against overweight people, who are attributed with bad qualities such as gluttony and laziness. And it’s normal for humans to respond emotionally to judgements that may be stigmatising, and to try and distance ourselves from stigmatised groups by looking for reasons not to trust such judgements.

So however sensitively worded the letter is, when it communicates that a child is overweight, this news will always trigger an impassioned and defensive reaction to the stigma implied.

From all the research I’ve read and conducted on this topic, it’s apparent that parents feel the health messages around childhood obesity speak to someone else’s priorities, rather than their own. Parents are not disinterested in their child’s long-term physical health – far from it – but they do feel a more pressing responsibility for their child’s well-being here and now.

The more we focus on the physical health risks of childhood obesity, while failing to acknowledge where this may conflict with parents’ own decisions, the more parents may feel we are challenging their right to decide what is best for their child’s health.

So what next?

Parents have rightly challenged some of the assumptions that weight feedback letters are based on. They have argued that providing feedback can actually risk harm to children, for example by triggering parent-child conversations about weight that wouldn’t otherwise happen. While researchers in other fields have pointed out that having an awareness of a child’s weight may not be a requirement for changes in diet or activity levels to take place.

Given that NCMP feedback letters show no objective effect on the uptake of child weight management services or reduction in obesity levels, perhaps public health professionals owe it to parents to consider alternatives, rather than press ahead with more of the same.

NCMP data tells us where childhood obesity is more prevalent at the community level – not just for individuals. So the data could also be used to target environmental or community-based responses, such as supporting after school physical activities in schools where obesity is most prevalent. It could also be used to invest in community development initiatives in areas of high obesity, for example by offering grants to community groups, setting up family healthy cooking and activity events and coordinating local media campaigns.

If public health professionals stop triggering parents’ defensive reactions by informing them that their child is overweight, they could be more receptive to initiatives which foster healthier behaviours. And surely that’s better for everyone.


Explore further:
Most parents don’t believe their child’s BMI report card

Provided by:
The Conversation

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles