Breaking News
November 24, 2017 - Video game improves balance in youth with autism
November 24, 2017 - Chromatrap introduces easy-to-use range of DNA kits for molecular biology applications
November 24, 2017 - Bacteria in the intestine can play important pacemaker role in peristalsis
November 24, 2017 - Resistance training promotes environmental quality of life and sense of coherence in older people
November 24, 2017 - Research suggests genome’s spatial organization as important switch for defining cell types
November 24, 2017 - Study highlights need for more clinical trials to improve treatment of children with heart disease
November 24, 2017 - Quickly Treating Mini-Stroke Can Cut Risk for Future Stroke
November 24, 2017 - Inclusion in mainstream school can exacerbate feelings of being ‘different’ in pupils with autism spectrum conditions
November 24, 2017 - Fat-busting ingredients in cinnamon
November 24, 2017 - IMeasureU introduces IMU Step for tracking movements of professional, amateur athletes
November 24, 2017 - Study uncovers key mechanism by which tumors develop resistance to radiation therapy
November 24, 2017 - This Thanksgiving, carve out time for lively discourse on end-of-life wishes
November 24, 2017 - Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease patients harbor infectious prions in their skin
November 24, 2017 - Call for ‘renewed focus’ on deadly threat from antibiotic resistance
November 24, 2017 - 14 signs your daughter may have ADHD
November 24, 2017 - ACA appears to have encouraged more people to use preventive care for heart health
November 23, 2017 - UVA researchers developing new tool to help cancer patients make complex care decisions
November 23, 2017 - SITC releases first consensus recommendations on managing immunotherapy side effects
November 23, 2017 - Research shows major shift in eye surgeries from hospitals to ambulatory surgery centers
November 23, 2017 - Multiple sclerosis drug can beat obstinate bacteria
November 23, 2017 - Maintaining sufficient vitamin D levels may help to prevent rheumatoid arthritis
November 23, 2017 - Heart disease risk factors linked to walking difficulties in people under age of 78
November 23, 2017 - UVA scientists working to find end-around method to stop triple-negative breast cancer
November 23, 2017 - Researchers develop new tool to share clinico-genomic data
November 23, 2017 - New analysis identifies five distinct patient clusters that may need different approaches to manage asthma
November 23, 2017 - Study shows education and poverty affect outcomes of total knee replacement
November 23, 2017 - Research paves way for development of vaccines against mycoplasma bacteria
November 23, 2017 - Season of festivities can increase opportunities to overindulge in alcohol
November 23, 2017 - Methotrexate drug holiday improves flu vaccine efficacy in rheumatoid arthritis patients
November 23, 2017 - Study identifies signaling pathway essential for growth of new blood vessels
November 23, 2017 - OBD presents results of immunotherapy studies at FNIH Biomarker Consortium Cancer Steering Committee’s annual meeting
November 23, 2017 - New study shows how SNO reaction may contribute to Parkinson’s disease
November 23, 2017 - Study highlights need to improve quality of cardiovascular care for HIV-positive adults
November 23, 2017 - New intelligence tool provides clarity to scientists in booming immuno-oncology field
November 23, 2017 - Cancer Survivors Can Develop PTSD, Too
November 23, 2017 - One step closer toward a treatment for Alzheimer’s disease?
November 23, 2017 - Scientists detect pathological prion protein in skin of CJD patients
November 23, 2017 - Bacterial colonization can function as a pacemaker for the intestine, study reveals
November 23, 2017 - Preclinical study shows clear path toward effective treatment for rare bone disease
November 23, 2017 - Displaced Puerto Ricans face obstacles getting health care
November 23, 2017 - High-intensity exercise improves memory, study finds
November 23, 2017 - Researchers compare shunts and stents to maintain blood flow in infants with heart disease
November 23, 2017 - Gold nanoparticles could potentially help in more effective drug delivery
November 23, 2017 - Moderate coffee consumption more likely to provide beneficial health outcomes
November 23, 2017 - ESMO Consortium Study advocates for equal access to quality cancer treatment across Asia
November 23, 2017 - Gut bacteria at young age can contribute to MS onset and progression, study suggests
November 23, 2017 - Australian government urged to sue tobacco companies
November 23, 2017 - OB/GYN vs PCP: Who Should Handle Sexual Health?
November 23, 2017 - A Teen Mom’s Stress May Harm Her Heart: MedlinePlus Health News
November 23, 2017 - How SORLA protects against Alzheimer’s disease
November 23, 2017 - Newly discovered drug-like compound may revolutionize treatment of autoimmune diseases
November 23, 2017 - Comprehensive review finds increasing number of new heart failure cases in the UK
November 23, 2017 - Leishmania adaptation to environmental changes results from frequent chromosomal amplifications
November 23, 2017 - People who use indoor firing ranges at risk of lead poisoning
November 23, 2017 - Tiny robots could pave way for treating illness in hard-to-reach areas of the body
November 23, 2017 - Study finds smokers wrongly believe Natural American Spirit cigarettes are healthier
November 23, 2017 - Cancer patients willing to swap drug efficacy for reduced risk of adverse events
November 23, 2017 - Oncologists find new biomarker for breast cancer having poor prognosis
November 23, 2017 - Scientists show how diaper phantoms can improve tumor measurements
November 23, 2017 - Metabolites significantly affected in chronic kidney disease, study finds
November 23, 2017 - AR and VR technologies hold potential to increase attractiveness of healthy foods
November 23, 2017 - Amazon Filters offers SupaPore H0P filters for fermentation applications
November 23, 2017 - FDA Approves Genentech’s Gazyva for Previously Untreated Advanced Follicular Lymphoma
November 23, 2017 - Does Sex Really Trigger Cardiac Arrest?: MedlinePlus Health News
November 23, 2017 - Baby-boomers and millennials more afflicted by the opioid epidemic
November 23, 2017 - UNC Lineberger professor receives The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society grant for immunotherapy research
November 23, 2017 - Researchers question exclusion of people with prior cancer history from clinical trials
November 23, 2017 - New mechanism in cancer cells to disarm attacking immune cells, study reveals
November 23, 2017 - Most U.S. Parents Can’t Find Good Childcare: Survey
November 23, 2017 - Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) Test: MedlinePlus Lab Test Information
November 23, 2017 - Opening windows and doors may improve sleep
November 23, 2017 - Research shows how HLF gene affects blood cell development
November 23, 2017 - Deaths due to diabetes higher than expected in Germany
November 23, 2017 - Study finds improvement in men’s health and negative health trend among women
November 23, 2017 - Study finds specific tumor environment that stimulates cancer cells to metastasize
November 23, 2017 - Problems with your hospital care? Speak up!
November 23, 2017 - Thyroid cancer survivors have higher risk for aging-related diseases
November 23, 2017 - Is a common shoulder surgery useless?
November 23, 2017 - Palliative care services help cancer patients
November 23, 2017 - Anti-diabetic drug can enhance repair of UV-induced DNA damage in cells of ‘Moon children’
Robotic-Assisted Surgery Adds Time, Costs Without Affecting Outcomes

Robotic-Assisted Surgery Adds Time, Costs Without Affecting Outcomes

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Action Points

  • Note that a large study comparing robotic to laparoscopic nephrectomy found no difference in outcomes, and substantially greater cost, with the robotic procedure.
  • A smaller study examining patients with rectal cancer demonstrated similar results.

Robotic-assisted surgery for kidney removal and rectal cancer was associated with higher costs and longer operating times and resulted in no improvement in short-term outcomes compared with laparoscopic procedures, according to two studies published in JAMA.

While laparoscopy has been shown to be safe and associated with few complications and shorter hospital stays for many procedures, robotic-assisted surgery has emerged as an alternate minimally invasive surgical option.

In the first study, investigators examined the trends in use of robotic-assisted radical nephrectomy and compared the outcomes and costs with those of laparoscopic radical nephrectomy. The study by In Gab Jeong, MD, PhD, of Stanford University Medical Center and Ulsan College of Medicine in Seoul, South Korea, and colleagues, included patients who underwent either robotic-assisted or laparoscopic radical nephrectomy at 416 U.S. hospitals between January 2003 and September 2015.

Of the 23,754 patients in the study, 18,575 underwent laparoscopic radical nephrectomy and 5,180 underwent robotic-assisted radical nephrectomy. The use of robotic-assisted surgery increased from 1.5% in 2003 to 27% in 2015.

The researchers found no significant differences between the two procedures in major postoperative complications, but the rate of prolonged operating time (>4 hours) for patients undergoing the robotic-assisted procedure was higher than for patients undergoing the laparoscopic procedure (46.3% versus 25.8%; risk difference 20.5%; 95% CI, 14.2% to 26.8%).

Significantly, the team said, robotic-assisted radical nephrectomy was associated with higher mean 90-day direct hospital costs ($19,530 versus $16,851; difference, $2,678; 95% CI, $838 to $4,519).

In the second study, a team led by David Jayne, MD, of Leeds Institute of Biological and Clinical Sciences of the University of Leeds in the U.K., evaluated the effect of robotic-assisted surgery compared with conventional laparoscopic surgery on the risk of having to convert to open laparotomy for patients undergoing resection for rectal cancer.

The study cohort included 471 patients with rectal adenocarcinoma suitable for curative resection from 29 sites across 10 countries. The patients were randomized to either robotic-assisted (n=237) or conventional laparoscopic rectal cancer resection (n=234).

Jayne et al found that the overall rate of conversion to open laparotomy was 10.1%, and the conversion rates for robotic-assisted and laparoscopic surgery were 8.1% and 12.2, respectively.

“There was no statistically significant difference between robotic-assisted and conventional laparoscopic surgery with respect to odds of conversion (adjusted OR = 0.61 [95% CI, 0.31 to 1.21]),” the team reported.

As for complication rates up to 6 months postoperatively, there again was no statistically significant difference between the two groups (14.8% in the conventional laparoscopic group and 15.3% in the robotic-assisted laparoscopic group), and the same held true for quality of life.

“These findings suggest that robotic-assisted laparoscopic surgery, when performed by surgeons with varying experience with robotic surgery, does not confer an advantage in rectal cancer resection.”

The researchers also analyzed the healthcare costs associated with the surgeries on the 190 U.S. and U.K patients included in the study.

The healthcare costs in the robotic-assisted laparoscopic group (mean of £11 853 or $13 668 [95% CI, $13 025-$14 350]) were higher than in the conventional laparoscopic group (mean of £10 874 or $12 556 [95% CI, $11 889- $13 223]). The difference was statistically significant (mean difference = £980 or $1132 [95% CI, $191-$2072].

The researchers found that the main drivers behind the increased costs associated with robotic-assisted surgery were longer operating times as well as the costs of the equipment.

In an editorial accompanying the two studies, Jason D. Wright, MD, chief of the Division of Gynecologic Oncology at Columbia University Medical Center in New York City, wrote that robotic-assisted surgery has been intensely marketed, “not only to physicians and hospitals, but also directly to patients.”

He noted that a previous study by his group suggested that robotic-assisted procedures increased costs by an average of 13% across a range of different operations, and that the findings reported for radical nephrectomy and rectal resection in the two new studies are consistent with those estimates. “Whether robotic-assisted surgery for some procedures represents ‘value’ for either the individual patient or the health care system is unlikely,” he added.

Wright also pointed out that there were limitations to the two studies: For example, the study by Jeong et al was observational and subject to selection bias and the influence of unmeasured confounders; and the study by Jayne et al was a relatively small clinical trial that had a lower than anticipated rate of the primary outcome of conversion to laparotomy.

“Accordingly, these findings should be replicated in other studies and with other procedures to determine the potential comparative benefits of robotic-assisted surgery,” Wright concluded.

  • Reviewed by
    F. Perry Wilson, MD, MSCE Assistant Professor, Section of Nephrology, Yale School of Medicine and Dorothy Caputo, MA, BSN, RN, Nurse Planner

2017-10-26T15:30:04-0400

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles