Breaking News
December 14, 2018 - Blood test helps identify distinct molecular signatures in children with cystic fibrosis
December 14, 2018 - Scientists use water to track electrical activity of nerve cells
December 14, 2018 - Recurrence of urinary tract infection may depend on bacterial strain, study shows
December 14, 2018 - GBT Announces U.S. FDA Agrees with its Proposal Relating to Accelerated Approval Pathway for Voxelotor for the Treatment of Sickle Cell Disease and GBT Plans to Submit New Drug Application (NDA)
December 14, 2018 - Partial Thromboplastin Time (PTT) Test: MedlinePlus Lab Test Information
December 14, 2018 - Common tactics for health promotion at work may be detrimental to employees with obesity
December 14, 2018 - Myths about migration and health not supported by available evidence
December 14, 2018 - Recent findings on rare genetic disorder may help develop new treatment options
December 14, 2018 - New drug shows promise in treating sarcomas
December 14, 2018 - Scientists perform lung lavage as new approach for tuberculosis diagnosis in rhinoceros
December 14, 2018 - Recent winners of the Nobel Medicine Prize
December 14, 2018 - KHN’s ‘What the Health?’ Insurance enrollment is lagging — and there are lots of reasons why
December 14, 2018 - Study assesses safety and efficacy of new treatment for pancreatic cancer
December 14, 2018 - Study finds drug targets for Ebola, Dengue, and Zika viruses
December 14, 2018 - Study highlights need for personalized approach to treat ICU acquired delirium
December 14, 2018 - Soot particles from road traffic significantly contribute to air pollution
December 14, 2018 - Massage helps relieve pain, improve mobility in patients with knee osteoarthritis
December 14, 2018 - Researchers explore home healthcare nurses’ knowledge attitudes toward infection control
December 14, 2018 - Average outpatient visit in the U.S. costs nearly $500, shows new study
December 14, 2018 - Reference Infliximab, Biosimilar Equivalent for Crohn’s Disease
December 14, 2018 - New contact lens to treat eye injuries
December 14, 2018 - Acne could have a genetic basis find researchers promising new cure
December 14, 2018 - Higher physical activity associated with improved mood
December 14, 2018 - New UGA study points to optimal hypertension treatment for stroke patients
December 14, 2018 - Study highlights factors that can reduce food cravings
December 14, 2018 - Researchers discover Ebola-fighting protein in human cells
December 14, 2018 - Fentanyl surpasses heroin in cause of U.S. drug overdose deaths
December 14, 2018 - When Heart Attack Strikes, Women Often Hesitate to Call for Help
December 14, 2018 - A warning about costume contacts
December 14, 2018 - Study examines link between peripheral artery disease and heart attack
December 14, 2018 - Researchers develop biotechnological tool to produce antifungal proteins in plants
December 14, 2018 - 3D-printed adaptive aids can benefit patients with arthritis
December 14, 2018 - Chronic bullying during adolescence impacts mental health
December 14, 2018 - Integral Molecular and Merus collaborate to develop bispecific antibody therapeutics
December 13, 2018 - Importance of cell cycle and cellular senescence in the placenta discovered
December 13, 2018 - Gold “nanoprisms” open new window into vessels and single cells
December 13, 2018 - Research findings could lead to new targets for cancer-fighting therapeutics
December 13, 2018 - Butantan Institute signs collaboration agreement with MSD to develop dengue vaccines
December 13, 2018 - Study explores how patients want to discuss symptoms with doctors
December 13, 2018 - RUDN medics first to gather scattered data on hepatitis morbidity in Somalia
December 13, 2018 - Age and gender disparities found in use of bed nets to prevent malaria in sub-Saharan Africa
December 13, 2018 - Caffeine therapy benefits developing brains of premature babies
December 13, 2018 - New review focuses on electrospinning techniques used in musculoskeletal tissue engineering
December 13, 2018 - A new division focused on human immune system
December 13, 2018 - Zogenix Announces Positive Phase 3 Trial Results on the Efficacy and Safety of Fintepla (ZX008) in Dravet Syndrome
December 13, 2018 - BCR ABL Genetic Test: MedlinePlus Lab Test Information
December 13, 2018 - Caffeinated beverages during pregnancy linked to lower birth weight babies
December 13, 2018 - Stanford Medicine Health Trends Report examines opportunity to democratize health care
December 13, 2018 - Obsessive-compulsive disorder may protect individuals from obesity
December 13, 2018 - Scientists investigate how a painful event is processed in the brain
December 13, 2018 - Genetic study reveals new insights into underlying causes of moderate-to-severe asthma
December 13, 2018 - Study uncovers new genetic clues to frontotemporal dementia
December 13, 2018 - Vitamin C supplementation for pregnant smokers may reduce harm to infants’ lungs
December 13, 2018 - New study reveals yin-yang personality of dopamine
December 13, 2018 - Research identifies nerve-signaling pathway behind sustained pain after injury
December 13, 2018 - Children with high levels of callous traits show widespread differences in brain structure
December 13, 2018 - Long-term Benefit of Steroid Injections for Knee Osteoarthritis Challenged
December 13, 2018 - Adding new channels to the brain remote control
December 13, 2018 - In the Spotlight: A different side of neuroscience
December 13, 2018 - Medical Marvels: Using immunotherapy for melanoma that spread to the brain
December 13, 2018 - Puzzles do not keep dementia away finds study
December 13, 2018 - New mouse model shows potential for rapid identification of promising muscular dystrophy therapies
December 13, 2018 - Study reveals urban and rural differences in prenatal exposure to essential and toxic elements
December 13, 2018 - New collaborative partnership in quest of novel antibiotics
December 13, 2018 - Single tau molecule holds clues to help diagnose neurodegeneration in its earliest stages
December 13, 2018 - AHA Scientific Statement: Low Risk of Side Effects for Statins
December 13, 2018 - What Is Acute Flaccid Myelitis?
December 13, 2018 - How bereaved people control their thoughts without knowing it
December 13, 2018 - Health care democratization underway, according to 2nd annual Stanford Medicine Health Trends Report | News Center
December 13, 2018 - Going Beyond a Single Color
December 13, 2018 - London-based startup launches ‘’ aiming to clean up CBD industry
December 13, 2018 - Loss of tight junction barrier protein results in gastric cancer development
December 13, 2018 - Novel way to efficiently deliver anti-parasitic medicines
December 13, 2018 - RKI publishes new data on disease prevention and utilization of medical services
December 13, 2018 - High-tech, flexible patches sewn into clothes could help to stay warm
December 13, 2018 - The CCA releases three reports on requests for medical assistance in dying
December 13, 2018 - Restoring Hair Growth on Scarred Skin? Mouse Study Could Show the Way
December 13, 2018 - Probiotic use may reduce antibiotic prescriptions, researchers say
December 13, 2018 - Drug repositioning strategy identifies potential new treatments for epilepsy
December 13, 2018 - Chronic rhinitis associated with hospital readmissions for asthma and COPD patients
Study shows no added benefit of pertuzumab combination in treatment of early breast cancer

Study shows no added benefit of pertuzumab combination in treatment of early breast cancer

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

For the third time since 2013, the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) examined in an early benefit assessment the added benefit of the drug pertuzumab in the treatment of HER2-positive breast cancer. The monoclonal antibody is always used in combination with trastuzumab and chemotherapy. Whereas the first two benefit assessments dealt with the treatment of advanced breast cancer and with neoadjuvant treatment, i.e. treatment administered before surgery, this assessment dealt with the advantages and disadvantages in adjuvant, i.e. supportive treatment of early breast cancer at high risk of recurrence.

The conclusion: For patients under 65 years of age, the combination therapy of pertuzumab, trastuzumab, a taxane, and, if applicable, an anthracycline is not better than the appropriate comparator therapy. There is even a hint of lesser benefit for patients aged 65 or older. A notable positive aspect was the methodologically solid validation of the surrogate outcome “disease-free survival” and the long follow-up observation period for symptoms and health-related quality of life.

APHINITY study showed no significant survival advantage

In its dossier, the drug manufacturer cited a single randomized controlled trial, from which it derived an added benefit of pertuzumab: A majority of the just over 4800 patients in the ongoing APHINITY study concurred with the approval of the drug. All patients had their primary tumours surgically removed before the start of the study. They were then randomly allocated in a 1:1 ratio to the arm with pertuzumab, trastuzumab and chemotherapy, or to the comparator arm with placebo, trastuzumab and chemotherapy. Trastuzumab and pertuzumab are monoclonal antibodies that aim to reduce the risk of recurrence by blocking the epidermal growth factor receptor HER2/neu, which is overexpressed in the cancer cells.

No statistically significant difference was shown between the treatment groups for the patient-relevant outcome “overall survival”. There was an indication of an added benefit of the pertuzumab combination in the morbidity outcome “recurrence”, but hints of lesser benefit for some symptoms. In the outcome category “health-related quality of life”, there were hints of an added benefit in two of nine areas, but also a hint of lesser benefit in one area. In addition, there were some indications of lesser benefit in the category of side effects, e.g. in form of more frequent serious adverse events.

In summary, the negative aspects outweighed the advantages of the new combination; there was even lesser benefit in comparison with the appropriate comparator therapy for patients over 65 years of age.

Up to two years of follow-up

In contrast to very advanced metastatic breast cancer, the treatment goal of early breast cancer is to cure the disease: Many patients still have a long life ahead of them. Many studies in the early benefit assessment hardly allow assessing whether deterioration of a symptom or of health-related quality of life, for example, are of a temporary nature as the data are only recorded during treatment. The present study with its long follow-up observation period for symptoms and quality of life (up to two years after the end of treatment), however, measured these outcomes both during treatment and at some interval after the end of treatment. This kind of study design allows to differentiate between temporary advantages or disadvantages of a treatment and long-term effects.

Methodologically exemplary surrogate validation

Due to the relatively long life expectancy of patients with early breast cancer, a significant advantage in overall survival was not expected to be shown during the study. The manufacturer therefore interpreted the so-called disease-free survival (such as the frequency of recurrences) as surrogate parameter for this outcome and derived an added benefit from it. This was based on the assumption that a positive treatment effect on such a substitute outcome also has a favourable effect on the actually relevant outcome. As it is by no means certain that this is the case, surrogates need to be thoroughly validated. The manufacturer conducted a validation study, where it collected data on disease-free survival and overall survival from other comparable studies and first investigated the strength of the correlation between these two entities.

These other studies differed from the APHINITY study, particularly regarding their comparator therapies. The surrogate validation is still conclusive because these studies also included patients with early breast cancer receiving adjuvant treatment with monoclonal antibodies, and hence the patient populations, the drug class, and the lines of treatment were the same. The correlation determined between disease-free survival and overall survival was of medium strength. Hence the researchers then established the so-called surrogate threshold effect (STE). The STE is the minimum effect on the surrogate that has to be shown to consider an effect on the clinical outcome to still be proven in case of medium correlation.

Effect too small for transferability to overall survival

Conclusions on overall survival based on disease-free survival would only be possible if the treatment effect on the surrogate in the APHINITY study was fully above this threshold. This was not the case, however.

Beate Wieseler, Head of IQWiG’s Drug Assessment Department notes: “The effect on the surrogate outcome was not large enough. Hence it is not certain that there is an effect on the patients’ overall survival, which is the outcome of actual interest.” According to Beate Wieseler, the surrogate validation did not change the assessment result in this assessment. “It does show, however, that the correlation-based validation methods we proposed in our 2010 report on surrogate outcomes, are practicable”, she adds.

G-BA decides on the extent of added benefit

The dossier assessment is part of the early benefit assessment according to the Act on the Reform of the Market for Medicinal Products (AMNOG) supervised by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA). After publication of the dossier assessment, the G-BA conducts a commenting procedure and makes a final decision on the extent of the added benefit.


About author

Related Articles