Breaking News
February 23, 2019 - AHA News: Why Are Black Women at Higher Risk of Dying From Pregnancy Complications?
February 23, 2019 - NIMH » Anxiety Disorders
February 23, 2019 - Autistic people urgently need access to tailored mental health support
February 23, 2019 - Newly designed molecule could benefit people with Friedrich’s Ataxia
February 23, 2019 - Chinese CRISPR twins may have better cognition and memory
February 23, 2019 - Study finds new genetic clues associated with asthma in African ancestry populations
February 23, 2019 - Fetal signaling pathways may offer future opportunities to treat lung damage
February 23, 2019 - Early-stage osteoarthritis drug wins prestigious innovation award
February 23, 2019 - Researchers report positive findings with dasotraline for ADHD in children ages 6-12
February 23, 2019 - News study reanalyzes the effects of noncaloric sweeteners on gut microbiota
February 23, 2019 - New device allows scientists to reproduce blow effects on the heart in lab
February 23, 2019 - Holy herb identified as a potential treatment for Alzheimer’s disease
February 23, 2019 - New technology platform digitally counts growth factors in single cells
February 23, 2019 - Surgery and other treatments offer viable options for adult scoliosis
February 23, 2019 - Reduced antibody adaptability may make the elderly more vulnerable to influenza
February 23, 2019 - Neighborhood income, education associated with risk of disability progression in MS patients
February 23, 2019 - 2019 guidelines for management of patients with atrial fibrillation
February 23, 2019 - Surprise rheumatoid arthritis discovery points to new treatment for joint inflammation
February 23, 2019 - A just-right fix for a tiny heart
February 23, 2019 - UMass Amherst scientist explores role of citrus peel in decreasing gut inflammation
February 23, 2019 - Owlstone Medical and Shanghai Renji Hospital collaborate to initiate breath biopsy lung cancer trial
February 23, 2019 - AMSBIO’s comprehensive portfolio of knock-out cell lines and lysates
February 23, 2019 - New app reliably determines physicians’ skills in forming accurate, efficient diagnoses
February 23, 2019 - Peripheral nerve injury can trigger the onset and spread of ALS, shows study
February 23, 2019 - Researchers uncover mechanisms that prevent tooth replacement in mice
February 23, 2019 - Once-a-day capsule offers new way to reduce symptoms of chronic breathlessness
February 23, 2019 - FDA Adds Boxed Warning for Increased Risk of Death with Gout Medicine Uloric (febuxostat)
February 23, 2019 - Phone-based intervention aids rheumatoid arthritis care
February 23, 2019 - Opioid epidemic makes eastern inroads and targets African-Americans
February 23, 2019 - New identified biomarker predicts patients who might benefit from HER2-targeted agents
February 23, 2019 - Study offers new insights into mechanisms of changes in erythrocytes under stress
February 23, 2019 - Antipsychotic polypharmacy may be beneficial for schizophrenia patients
February 23, 2019 - Researchers investigate how marijuana and tobacco co-use affects quit attempts by smokers
February 23, 2019 - Patients with diabetes mellitus have high risk of stable ischemic heart disease
February 23, 2019 - Transparency on healthcare prices played key role in Arizona health system’s turnaround
February 23, 2019 - A comprehensive, multinational review of peppers around the world
February 23, 2019 - Study finds modest decrease in burnout among physicians
February 23, 2019 - A simple change can drastically reduce unnecessary tests for urinary tract infections
February 23, 2019 - Deep Learning-Enhanced Device Detects Diabetic Retinopathy
February 23, 2019 - Researchers discover new binding partner for amyloid precursor protein
February 23, 2019 - Modest decrease seen in burnout among physicians, researchers say | News Center
February 23, 2019 - Transplanting bone marrow of young mice into old mice prevents cognitive decline
February 23, 2019 - Mogrify to accelerate novel IP and cell therapies using $3.7m USD funding
February 23, 2019 - Johns Hopkins study describes cells that may help speed bone repair
February 23, 2019 - Scientists demonstrate influence of food odors on proteostasis
February 23, 2019 - Researchers unlock the secret behind reproduction of fish called ‘Mary’
February 23, 2019 - Acupuncture Could Help Ease Menopausal Symptoms
February 23, 2019 - Researchers use AI to detect early signs of Alzheimer’s
February 23, 2019 - On recovery, vulnerability and ritual: An exhibit in white | News Center
February 23, 2019 - Memory Stored in Unexpected Region of the Brain
February 23, 2019 - Several health experts worldwide gather at EUDONORGAN event
February 23, 2019 - Discovery of potent compound in native California shrub may lead to treatment for Alzheimer’s
February 22, 2019 - Researchers create new map of the brain’s own immune system
February 22, 2019 - ICHE’s reviews on surgical infections, unnecessary urine tests, and nurses’ role in antibiotic stewardship
February 22, 2019 - UK Research and Innovation invests £200 million to create new generation of AI leaders
February 22, 2019 - Takeda collaboration to boost fight against Alzheimer’s and other neurodegenerative diseases
February 22, 2019 - Heavy drinking may change DNA, leading to increased craving for alcohol
February 22, 2019 - U.S. opioid deaths jump fourfold in 20 years; epidemic shifts to Eastern states | News Center
February 22, 2019 - 5 Questions with William Turner on Diversity in Medicine
February 22, 2019 - HHS Finalizes Rule Seeking To Expel Planned Parenthood From Family Planning Program
February 22, 2019 - Researchers uncover biochemical pathway that may help identify drugs to treat Alzheimer’s
February 22, 2019 - Biologist uses new grant to find ways to eliminate schistosomiasis
February 22, 2019 - Bag-mask ventilation to help patients breathe during intubation prevents complications
February 22, 2019 - AbbVie Announces New Drug Application Accepted for Priority Review by FDA for Upadacitinib for Treatment of Moderate to Severe Rheumatoid Arthritis
February 22, 2019 - Nature versus nurture and addiction
February 22, 2019 - New website connects researchers with data experts, resources | News Center
February 22, 2019 - Today’s Concerns About Drug Prices Echo The Past
February 22, 2019 - CT and Doppler equipment have low accuracy in detecting cerebral vasospasm and ischemia
February 22, 2019 - Study finds out similarity in function between healthy retina cell and tumor cell
February 22, 2019 - CWRU awarded NIH grant to identify effective treatments for intimate partner violence
February 22, 2019 - Oncotype DX Not Cost-Effective for Low-Risk Breast Cancer
February 22, 2019 - Scientists discover new type of immune cells that are essential for forming heart valves
February 22, 2019 - Talk About Déjà Vu: Senators Set To Re-Enact Drug Price Hearing Of 60 Years Ago
February 22, 2019 - Genetic defect linked to pediatric liver disease identified
February 22, 2019 - New cellular atlas could provide a deeper insight into blinding diseases
February 22, 2019 - Growing number of cancer survivors, fewer providers point to challenge in meeting care needs
February 22, 2019 - Innovative compound offers a new therapeutic approach to treat multiple sclerosis
February 22, 2019 - $1.5 million grant to develop opioid treatment program for jail detainees
February 22, 2019 - FDA’s new proposed rule would update regulatory requirements for sunscreen products in the U.S
February 22, 2019 - Most Hip, Knee Replacements Last Decades, Study Finds
LDR brachytherapy for treating early-stage prostate cancer lacks conclusive data

LDR brachytherapy for treating early-stage prostate cancer lacks conclusive data

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Interstitial brachytherapy uses slightly radioactive particles implanted into the prostate to deliver radiation directly to the tumour (low-dose-rate, LDR). Due to a lack of conclusive data, it still remains an unresolved issue as to whether this procedure has advantages compared with other treatments in men with localized prostate cancer. This is the sobering conclusion reached in the rapid report published by the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) on 16 November 2018.

About eleven years after its first benefit assessment and about seven years after a search update, the Institute again analysed current studies. In 2011, the Institute was very optimistic that gaps in knowledge could be closed before long as the self-administration in the German health care system had cleared the way for a large-scale German study in 2009. However, this study (PREFERE) was terminated prematurely in late 2016. Since there are no new data, the results of the earlier IQWiG assessments remain valid.

Comparison of therapy alternatives

Prostate cancer is potentially curable as long as the tumour is still confined to the prostate gland. Several options are available for the treatment of such a localized tumour: Besides complete surgical removal of the prostate (radical prostatectomy, RP) or radiation with an external radiation source (external beam radiotherapy, EBRT), permanent interstitial LDR brachytherapy offers another therapy option. In this treatment, small radioactive particles are permanently implanted in the prostate via specific needles to deliver radiation directly to the tumour.

As, even without treatment, prostate tumours either stop growing or grow very slowly in many patients, the fourth option to be considered is a specific form of watchful waiting called active surveillance.

Usable data from two new studies

In their current search, the researchers identified one additional randomized controlled trial (RCT), which compared LDR brachytherapy with prostatectomy (RP). The SPIRIT study was terminated prematurely, but IQWiG was able to include the data of the patients randomly allocated (34) up to that time point.

The results of three further newly included studies, all of which were prospective, comparative cohort studies, were only usable in one case. In this study, LDR brachytherapy was compared both with RP and with radiotherapy (EBRT).

In addition, a newer publication on a study that had already been included in the 2011 update was relevant for the current rapid report. This study also had three arms (LDR brachytherapy/RP/EBRT).

No statements on survival possible

The Institute could extract data on patient-relevant outcomes from these three sources. But none of them reported results on overall survival or on disease-free survival, hence the only outcomes referring to the cure of the disease.

In its current assessment, the Institute again did not use the data on the so-called PSA-based recurrence-free survival as this remains to be a non-validated surrogate.

As in the earlier assessments, it has not been proven that, compared with the alternative treatments, LDR brachytherapy is at least equivalent in respect of survival. It is therefore possible that patients who undergo LDR brachytherapy die earlier or have a shorter disease-free survival period.

Possible advantages in other treatment goals not interpretable

Regarding other outcomes, the results are partly in favour, partly to the disadvantage of LDR brachytherapy. There are indications that catheterization is required for a longer period of time than in EBRT. In contrast, brachytherapy seems to result in less impairment of sexual function than RP. With the persistent data gaps regarding survival, these results cannot be reliably classified, however. “As long as we do not know how reliably brachytherapy works against cancer, this does not suffice to speak of a benefit,” says Stefan Lange, IQWiG’s Deputy Director.

Various suspensions of G-BA consultations

The Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) commissioned a first benefit assessment in 2004. After the negative result of the first report, the topic was included in the agenda again in 2009. Since evidence was still lacking, the Committee initiated a large-scale study (PREFERE). The acronym reflected the intention to consider patient preferences in the study. An unprecedented concerted effort of the German Cancer Aid and the statutory health insurance funds secured study funding of up to 25 million euros.

In 2013, the G-BA decided to further suspend consultations until 2030, when the results of the PREFERE study would be available.

IQWiG very much welcomed this development: Instead of making decisions on an uncertain evidence base, in an exemplary fashion, the self-administration had provided the preconditions to close existing gaps in knowledge. “In any event this approach will improve the quality of health care of patients with early-stage prostate cancer,” states a 2011 press release.

False hopes

Yet it turned out differently: In late 2016, the study investigators announced the premature end of the PREFERE study. They had not succeeded in recruiting enough patients for participation. Stefan Lange calls this development “an embarrassment not only for the professional societies, but for the entire research and health care system”.

He adds: “The main reason why this unprecedented project, which was funded entirely without industrial sponsoring, failed was that too many of the parties involved lacked commitment. Some study centres did succeed in recruiting a sufficient number of patients for PREFERE. Hence, the study was principally feasible, even though interested expert groups denied this. Now we are almost where we were in 2004.”

Consequently, the G-BA resumed the consultations in 2017, and commissioned IQWiG with the update. Its decision will be based on the current rapid report with the conclusion: benefit unclear, reliable evidence is lacking.

Source:

https://www.iqwig.de/en/press/press-releases/benefit-of-ldr-brachytherapy-in-patients-with-early-stage-prostate-cancer-is-still-unclear.10524.html

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles