Breaking News
December 17, 2017 - AHA: Regional Plan for Cath Lab Activation Improves STEMI Outcomes
December 17, 2017 - Breathing exercises help asthma patients with quality of life
December 17, 2017 - Researchers explore how toxic protein clusters linked to Parkinson’s disrupt brain cells
December 17, 2017 - Autism traits linked to risk of depression, suicidal thoughts in people with psychosis
December 17, 2017 - Jimmie Holland’s Long Medical Odyssey
December 17, 2017 - Controversial MS Treatment Found to Be Ineffective: MedlinePlus Health News
December 17, 2017 - Time of day affects test results for asthma, researchers find
December 17, 2017 - Scientists create atomic scale map that tracks how brain signals connect to neurons
December 17, 2017 - Tips for buying safe toys during the holidays – and year-round
December 17, 2017 - CardioBrief: Will Entresto Sell Big After All?
December 17, 2017 - Water baths as good as bleach baths for treating eczema
December 17, 2017 - Valley fever cases see sharp increase in November, say UVA experts
December 17, 2017 - New Insight on Killer Fungus Threatening Bats
December 17, 2017 - Early Atherosclerosis Defies ‘Normal’ Cholesterol
December 17, 2017 - CRF1 stress receptor is regulator of mast cell activity during stress
December 17, 2017 - CREST Failed to Dampen Enthusiasm for Carotid Stenting in Elderly
December 17, 2017 - Rising levels of HIV drug resistance
December 17, 2017 - Aging brain’s failure to coordinate deep-sleep brainwaves makes older adults forget
December 17, 2017 - Rural Workers Have Higher Exposures to COPD-Causing Pollutants
December 17, 2017 - Don’t Delay Hip Fracture Surgery. Here’s Why: MedlinePlus Health News
December 17, 2017 - NIH launches HIV prevention trial of long-acting injectable medication in women
December 17, 2017 - Op-Ed: Get Ready for a Tsunami of ECGs
December 17, 2017 - Observation care may save more than thought
December 17, 2017 - Scientists explore effectiveness of action video games to combat dyslexia
December 17, 2017 - Teens Acting Badly? Smog Could Be to Blame
December 17, 2017 - FDA Says ‘Yes’ to Short-Acting Insulin Admelog
December 17, 2017 - Vaping popular among teens; opioid misuse at historic lows
December 17, 2017 - Lower Urinary Symptoms Occur in Almost All Patients with SSc
December 17, 2017 - Genetic mutation in extended Amish family in Indiana protects against aging and increases longevity (Update)
December 16, 2017 - Butler Hospital launches international Alzheimer’s disease prevention study
December 16, 2017 - iMedicalApps: Virtual Reality Boosts Self-Confidence for Med Students
December 16, 2017 - Researchers validate five new genes responsible for Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis
December 16, 2017 - New genetic analysis of candidiasis reveals surprising fungal sex secrets
December 16, 2017 - New high precision machine-learning model could help accelerate drug discovery
December 16, 2017 - Groundbreaking gene therapy trial brings cure for hemophilia closer
December 16, 2017 - Racial Differences Seen in IgG4 Disease
December 16, 2017 - Treacher Collins Syndrome
December 16, 2017 - New approach to tracking how deadly ‘superbugs’ travel could slow their spread
December 16, 2017 - Muscle paralysis may promote breakdown of bones
December 16, 2017 - WSU scientists create injectable dye to track progression of diseases
December 16, 2017 - Kaiser Permanente delivers clot-busting drugs to stroke patients more than twice as fast as national rates
December 16, 2017 - Some Great Holiday Foods for Weight Loss
December 16, 2017 - Shared Decision-Making Strategies for Lung Ca Screening Get High Marks
December 16, 2017 - Lactic acid bacteria can protect against Influenza A virus, study finds
December 16, 2017 - Cancer immunotherapy’s effectiveness may depend on patient’s genetic makeup
December 16, 2017 - Researchers explore patient-doctor conversations, best practices linked to opioid tapering
December 16, 2017 - ‘Virtual child’ to help professionals learn key techniques to treat children with autism
December 16, 2017 - IU scientists discover way to make drug treatment more successful against malaria
December 16, 2017 - Prostate cancer researchers find significant disparities between two liquid biopsy providers
December 16, 2017 - ED-Diagnosed Lung Ca Patients Worse Off: Clin Onc News Report
December 16, 2017 - Calcium in Urine Test: MedlinePlus Lab Test Information
December 16, 2017 - Pregnancy-related conditions taken together leave moms—and dads—at risk
December 16, 2017 - Research uncovers mechanism implicated in defective function of tumor-associated dendritic cells
December 16, 2017 - OncoBreak: Stubborn Racial Disparities; Paid Medical Leave & Chemo; DIY Gene Tests
December 16, 2017 - Critical link between obesity and diabetes has been identified
December 16, 2017 - Transfusion dependence reduces access to high-quality end-of-life care for leukemia patients
December 16, 2017 - Porvair and Suzhou Tianlong Bio to develop epigenetic analysis technologies
December 16, 2017 - FDA Approves Ixifi (infliximab-qbtx), a Biosimilar to Remicade
December 16, 2017 - Morning Break: Trump to Get Check-Up; Cancerous Transplant; Death Knell for MIPS?
December 16, 2017 - First transcatheter implant for diastolic heart failure successful
December 16, 2017 - ‘Sushi-like’ nanodiscs provide structural snapshots of misfolding proteins
December 16, 2017 - Inherited gene variation may be to blame for poor survival of patients with early-onset breast cancer
December 16, 2017 - Sign-up deadline is Friday, but some people may get extra time
December 16, 2017 - Higher Booze Taxes Might Pay Off for Public Health
December 16, 2017 - Regular Activity in Midlife Spares Joints in Women
December 16, 2017 - Rain May Not Cause Achy Joints After All: MedlinePlus Health News
December 16, 2017 - MedDiet adherence doesn’t affect acute heart failure mortality
December 16, 2017 - HKBU experts develop new generation of smart anti-cancer drug molecules
December 16, 2017 - Chronic Kidney Disease Audit finds wide variations in coding of CKD patients in primary care
December 16, 2017 - Scientists use nanoparticles to fight Mucoviscidosis
December 16, 2017 - Increasing physical activity decreases risk of death from lymphoma
December 16, 2017 - Fear compromises the health, well-being of immigrant families, survey finds
December 16, 2017 - Rejected antibiotic candidate could be worth a second look, research finds
December 16, 2017 - Is Nation on the Right Track to Combat Opioid Crisis?
December 16, 2017 - Arthritis No Longer Just a Disease of the Old: MedlinePlus Health News
December 16, 2017 - Study reveals biology behind why muscle stem cells respond differently to aging or injury
December 16, 2017 - Family members without inherited mutation have increased risk of melanoma
December 16, 2017 - Researchers reveal previously unknown mechanism that inhibits cells’ ability to develop into tumors
December 16, 2017 - Studies highlight potential of fMRI applications to detect, treat epilepsy in children
December 16, 2017 - Active surveillance proposed as first-line approach to manage patients with low-risk PMC of the thyroid
Decompression surgery may offer no additional benefit for people with shoulder impingement

Decompression surgery may offer no additional benefit for people with shoulder impingement

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print

Decompression surgery does not reduce shoulder pain any more than placebo surgery for people with shoulder impingement – when the tendon rubs and catches in the joint, according to the first placebo-controlled trial in shoulder surgery published in The Lancet.

Furthermore, although both types of surgery were slightly more effective at reducing subacromial shoulder pain compared to no treatment, the difference was small and not likely to result in a noticeable effect.

In the USA, shoulder pain accounts for 4.5 million visits to the doctor each year, and 2.4% of all GP visits in the UK. For subacromial shoulder pain, treatment options include subacromial decompression, which is one of the most commonly used surgeries in orthopedics. In England, the number of surgeries has risen from 2523 in 2000, to 21355 in 2010.

The authors of the study say the findings question the value of this operation, and that patients considering undergoing the operation should be informed.

“Over the past three decades, patients with this form of shoulder pain and clinicians have accepted this surgery in the belief that it provides reliable relief of symptoms, and has low risk of adverse events and complications. However, the findings from our study suggest that surgery might not provide a clinically significant benefit over no treatment, and that there is no benefit of decompression over placebo surgery.” says co-chief investigator Professor Andrew Carr, National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) Biomedical Research Centre, University of Oxford, UK.

The study involved 32 hospitals and 51 surgeons across the UK. In the study, 90, 94 and 90 people who had suffered shoulder pain for at least three months despite having physiotherapy and steroid injections underwent decompression surgery, placebo surgery or no treatment, respectively. They completed questionnaires about their level of pain and function at six months.

Decompression surgery is a keyhole surgery that involves removing a small area of bone and soft tissue in the shoulder joint to open up the joint and prevent rubbing or catching when the arm is lifted. In the placebo surgery, surgeons conducted a procedure to look inside the joint where the joint was inspected but no tissue was removed.

Both surgeries were completed as keyhole procedures to ensure that patients were not aware of which surgery they had had. Surgery participants also had one to four physiotherapy sessions afterwards, while those having no treatment only had a check-up appointment three months after the start of the trial.

Six and 12 months after they entered the trial, the participants completed questionnaires rating their symptoms, including pain (from 0-48, with a higher number meaning less pain). Overall, symptoms diminished in all three groups from the start of the trial.

At six months, people who had had decompression surgery and those who had had placebo surgery rated their pain and function at a similar level, with no statistical difference (32.7 points and 34.2 points, respectively).

Comparatively, both forms of surgery showed a small benefit over no treatment (rated at 29.4 points in the no treatment group), however, the difference is unlikely to result in a noticeable difference in symptoms.

The authors suggest that the difference could be attributable to a number of factors, including a placebo effect related to surgery, a nocebo effect related to having no treatment, other unintended effects of the placebo surgery, or because people undergoing surgery were given physiotherapy and told to rest.

“Our findings call into question the value of shoulder decompression surgery for this group of patients, and should be communicated to patients and doctors considering this type of surgery. In light of our results, other ways to treat shoulder impingement could be considered, such as painkillers, physiotherapy and steroid injections.” says co-chief investigator Professor David Beard, University of Oxford, UK.

During the trial, six participants had a frozen shoulder (two people in each treatment group) related to the study, and one person in the placebo surgery group underwent decompression surgery for pain.

The authors note some limitations to their study, including that some patients did not continue with their assigned treatment (23%, 42% and 12% of decompression, placebo surgery and no treatment participants, respectively). For example, some patients assigned to surgery did not undergo treatment as their symptoms improved, and other patients assigned to no treatment chose to undergo decompression surgery. However, the authors found that the effects of this do not impact on the results.

In addition, there were long waiting times within the study meaning some people who had only recently had surgery and may have still been recovering were compared with people who had had no treatment for six months, which may affect the results. On average, people assigned to decompression surgery waited 90 days for their surgery, and people assigned to placebo surgery waited 82 days.

The study did not look at the recurrence of pain after a year, but the authors state that it is unlikely that one group would show larger improvements long-term when they have not done so in a year after surgery.

Writing in a linked Comment, Dr Berend Schreurs, Radboud University Medical Center, the Netherlands, says:

The findings send a strong message that the burden of proof now rests on those who wish to defend the standpoint that shoulder arthroscopy is more effective than non-surgical interventions. Hopefully, these findings from a well respected shoulder research group will change daily practice. The costs of surgery are high, and although the low occurrence of complications might suggest that the surgery is benign, there is no indication for surgery without possible gain.

Source:

http://www.thelancet.com/

Tagged with:

About author

Related Articles