Breaking News
November 21, 2018 - Study explores individual and organizational risk factors for one-year mortality in ICU survivors
November 21, 2018 - Pulmonologists want more information on inhalation devices for COPD
November 21, 2018 - Cessation fatigue predicts relapse rate after attempts to quit smoking
November 21, 2018 - Special care should be taken with drugs that inhibit epigenetic factors, study suggests
November 21, 2018 - More than one in ten heavy cannabis users experience withdrawal after quitting cannabis
November 21, 2018 - Reflections on the California fires
November 21, 2018 - Donna Lynne Appointed to Key Leadership Role at CUIMC
November 21, 2018 - Smoke-free laws associated with reduced systolic blood pressure
November 21, 2018 - Achieving new guideline blood pressure goals may prevent 3 million cardiovascular events
November 21, 2018 - LDR brachytherapy for treating early-stage prostate cancer lacks conclusive data
November 21, 2018 - Purified omega-3 and aspirin reduce pre-cancerous bowel polyps, shows study
November 21, 2018 - Study warns that potential epigenetic therapy may boost lung cancer stem cells
November 21, 2018 - Noise pollution in hospital impact quality and safety of healthcare
November 21, 2018 - Higher Risk for Amputation, DKA With SGLT2 Inhibitors for T2DM
November 21, 2018 - Researchers stop ‘sneaky’ cancer cells in their tracks
November 21, 2018 - People who are afraid to draw their blood over-estimate the risk of fainting
November 21, 2018 - Personalized physical exercise reverses functional, cognitive deterioration in the elderly
November 21, 2018 - COPD linked to obesity in older women who have never smoked
November 21, 2018 - AHA: Cold-Weather Drinks Are Here, But Watch Out for the Calories
November 21, 2018 - Crowds line up at 1st East Coast pot shops
November 21, 2018 - Merck declares 2018 Life Science Award winners
November 21, 2018 - Many people underestimate the impact of sprains, say foot scientists
November 21, 2018 - Lower levels of protein make squamous carcinoma cells more invasive
November 21, 2018 - Study highlights a new predictor of type 2 diabetes
November 21, 2018 - NTU and TTSH join forces to improve doctor-patient communication
November 21, 2018 - New low-cost injectable hydrogel could help wounds heal faster
November 21, 2018 - Merck Announces Winners of 2018 Life Science Awards
November 21, 2018 - Check your medical records for dangerous errors
November 21, 2018 - Amount of weight regain after bariatric surgery helps predict health risks
November 21, 2018 - Heart failure patients with stronger hearts have more depressive symptoms, lower quality of life
November 21, 2018 - Women can be as resilient as men in undertaking arduous physical activity
November 21, 2018 - Receptor structure could be key to developing new osteoporosis drugs
November 21, 2018 - Researchers identify human white matter pathway associated with individual variability in human stereoacuity
November 21, 2018 - Vitamin D critical to early development of vertebrates, study suggests
November 21, 2018 - Myriad biological, societal factors that impact CKD severity for children of African descent
November 21, 2018 - Isofol Announces Initiation of a Pivotal Phase 3 Clinical Trial of arfolitixorin for the Treatment of Metastatic Colorectal Cancer
November 21, 2018 - Experts offer more clarity on managing common ankle fractures
November 21, 2018 - About 300 million bits of DNA are missing from basic reference genome, report scientists
November 21, 2018 - Study explores how the moving brain processes visual information
November 21, 2018 - Biomedical engineers stop cancer cells from moving and spreading
November 21, 2018 - Gut protein mutations protect against spikes in blood glucose levels
November 21, 2018 - First probabilistic atlas of thalamus nuclei to better understand the brain
November 21, 2018 - Peanut allergies could soon have a drug treatment
November 21, 2018 - Vanderbilt researchers isolate antibody that can neutralize West Nile virus
November 21, 2018 - KHN’s ‘What the Health?’ Health nerd books for the holidays
November 21, 2018 - MDMA could help gain trust but does not make one naive find researchers
November 21, 2018 - Study uncovers new mechanism controlling the master cancer regulator
November 21, 2018 - Online communication technologies could stave off depression among seniors, shows study
November 21, 2018 - FDA Approves Gamifant (emapalumab-lzsg) for Primary Hemophagocytic Lymphohistiocytosis
November 21, 2018 - Artificial intelligence predicts treatment effectiveness
November 21, 2018 - A bicyclist’s road to recovery after traumatic brain injury
November 21, 2018 - New research project to combat obesity, type 2 diabetes receives NIH funding
November 21, 2018 - Humans play key role in distribution and transmission of Bartonella bacteria
November 21, 2018 - First modeling system developed for testing age-specific human immune responses to vaccines
November 21, 2018 - FDA Alert: Gilenya (fingolimod): Drug Safety Communication
November 21, 2018 - Uric Acid Test: MedlinePlus Lab Test Information
November 21, 2018 - Researchers use genetics to predict response to antipsychotic medications
November 21, 2018 - Proposal to include the price of drugs in television ads is flawed, Stanford scholar writes
November 21, 2018 - Disrupting reproduction strategy of disease-causing parasites could help fight malaria
November 20, 2018 - ACAAI: Almost 2 Percent of Children Have Milk Allergy
November 20, 2018 - Congenital anomalies of kidney and urinary tract – Genetics Home Reference
November 20, 2018 - Can video games improve the health of older adults with schizophrenia?
November 20, 2018 - Can flicking a molecular switch restore the aging immune system’s competence?
November 20, 2018 - Restek launches new Oregon cannabis pesticide standards
November 20, 2018 - Health sector coalition urges Government to safeguard patients in future UK-EU relationship
November 20, 2018 - Study evaluates second-hand marijuana smoke exposure among children
November 20, 2018 - Scientists identify three genes responsible for recurrent molar pregnancies
November 20, 2018 - Researchers identify multisystem disorder caused by bi-allelic variants in CCDC47 gene
November 20, 2018 - Dining Out With Allergies Is Tough, But These Steps Can Help
November 20, 2018 - Breastfeeding protects infants from antibiotic-resistant bacteria
November 20, 2018 - AI matched, outperformed radiologists in screening X-rays for certain diseases | News Center
November 20, 2018 - Adolescents increasingly choose marijuana over cigarettes, alcohol
November 20, 2018 - World’s first medical imaging scanner produces diagnostic scan of the whole human body
November 20, 2018 - Cytocybernetics receives NIMH award to move into neuronal drug development
November 20, 2018 - Researchers discover new information on pathological mechanisms of Alzheimer’s disease
November 20, 2018 - ‘Unknown’ enzyme may be key to new treatment for inflammatory diseases
November 20, 2018 - Recreational drug may help people regain trust in others
November 20, 2018 - Researchers identify gene vital for post-stroke recovery
November 20, 2018 - Scientists identify novel target for neuron regeneration, functional recovery in spinal cord injury
November 20, 2018 - Potential new therapeutic approach developed for synovial sarcoma
Can you rely on the drugs that your doctor prescribes?

Can you rely on the drugs that your doctor prescribes?

image_pdfDownload PDFimage_print
The reliability of a new guideline for the management of chronic hepatitis C is questionable, given the financial conflicts of interest documented by its authors. Credit: Shutterstock

The Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) has just published a new guideline for the management of hepatitis C—a disease that is underdiagnosed and undertreated in Canada.

This guideline is aimed at doctors and details recent advances in treating adults with chronic hepatitis C virus infection. It was produced by a committee from the Canadian Association for the Study of the Liver (CASL).

As the complexity of medical care grows exponentially, clinical guidelines such as this become increasingly important in helping doctors weave their way through the diagnosis and treatment of disease. As the number of guidelines increases, so too does their influence.

Well-constructed medical guidelines can be a boon to patient care, but poor guidelines have the potential for harm. There are two interrelated threats. The first is when committee members have a financial conflict of interest (FCOI) with companies producing products recommended in the guidelines. The second occurs when guidelines rely on poor quality evidence.

In the lead up to the Global Hepatitis Summit 2018, to be held in Toronto on June 14-17, we believe there are reasons to be concerned about this new hepatitis C guideline on both counts.

First, all eight authors of the CMAJ article, including the chair, declared FCOI with companies that produced the drugs recommended in the guideline. Second, the committee did not include an expert on evidence evaluation or someone representing the public or patients.

Do guidelines recommend the best drugs?

One of the authors of this article (Joel Lexchin) was part of a study that looked at FCOI in Canadian medical guidelines. We examined 28 guidelines that recommended drug treatment for a wide variety of diseases.

In more than 25 per cent of these documents, over half of the authors disclosed FCOI with manufacturers of drugs that they recommended.

The guideline for the treatment of patients with major depressive disorder from the American Psychiatric Association was studied by Lisa Cosgrove, the second author of this article. Financial ties to industry were disclosed by all members of this guideline development committee.

The presence of this FCOI may have been the reason why fewer than half of the studies cited in support of the recommendations met criteria for high quality and why 17 per cent did not measure clinically relevant results.

To guard against the corruption of guidelines, safeguards have been put in place. The U.S. Institute of Medicine (IOM), now the National Academy of Medicine, has recommendations about the membership on guideline committees. According to them, the chair and the majority of members should be free of FCOI and the committee should include an expert in the evaluation of evidence and a patient or public representative.

When the highly respected Cochrane organization produces medical guidelines, it explains in detail why studies are included or excluded. It also evaluates the multiple sources of bias that potentially exist in all studies.

The point about bias is extremely important as there is good evidence that studies financed by drug and device manufacturers are much more likely to report positive results and conclusions, compared with studies with any other source of funding.

Finally, guidelines produced by industry-tied authors tend to recommend expensive drugs despite a lack of evidence for their safety and efficacy.

3D illustration of the hepatitis C virus (HCV). Credit: Shutterstock

Silent on many questions

So, how valuable is a guideline for the management of hepatitis C, in which eight authors declared FCOI with recommended drug producers? How reliable are the recommendations from a committee that did not document how evidence was evaluated or include a public or patient representative?

The committee did attempt to get around some of these deficiencies. First the guideline explicitly states: “No funding, direct or in kind, was provided to the guideline panel for this work.” Second, “in order to manage competing interests, the final guideline was vetted by the Canadian Association for the Study of the Liver membership, and specifically by the association’s executive.” Third, the “guideline was circulated by email to community organizations that represented patients.”

Who were the community organizations and did they have ties with the companies making the drugs the guideline recommends? The guideline is silent on these questions.

Who is on the executive of CASL? Do they as individuals have links with industry? Does the association itself have links?

Getting even partial answers to these questions requires some digging. A simple Google search on “Canadian Association for the Study of the Liver” doesn’t produce any direct links. The closest is a link to the Canadian Liver Journal. Visit this page, click around a few more times and eventually you get to the CASL website.

There are 33 people on the executive board including three of the guideline committee members; so, executive committee members were reviewing what they themselves had written.

Did the other 30 members have any FCOI to declare? There’s no information about these people on the website. The website does say that CASL only endorses requests produced by a not-for-profit organization and that it “does not endorse or support any commercial diagnostic or therapeutic products.”

But Gilead Science, Merck and AbbVie were all 2018 sponsors of Association Hepatology Fellowships. Gilead and AbbVie both produce hepatitis C drugs and Merck was working in this field until October 2017.

Does CASL get money from drug companies? Silence once more.

There is nothing in the guideline about why studies were included or excluded, nothing about how the information was abstracted from the studies and nothing about whether they were checked for biases.

Guidelines must be bias-free

The appearance of this guideline in the CMAJ raises serious questions about the journal’s standards for publishing guidelines. The article was peer reviewed and FCOI was declared, but should the journal do more?

Should it require the composition of guideline committees to conform to the standards set by the National Academy of Medicine?

Should there have to be information about FCOI of the organization sponsoring the guidelines?

Should there have to be explicit information about how studies were selected and evaluated?

Guidelines have to be seen as free of bias in order for doctors to have confidence in them. The new hepatitis C guideline published by the Canadian Medical Association Journal fails the bias test.


Explore further:
Hepatitis C guideline recommends screening for all people born 1945-1975

Journal reference:
Canadian Medical Association Journal

Provided by:
The Conversation

About author

Related Articles